Fish compete with college students on math test
Mosquitofish perform as well as college students on a basic numbers test.
By Bryan NelsonTue, Jan 11 2011 at 12:16 AM EST
7
MOSQUITOFISH: Capable of recognizing quantities as large as 200, these mathematically minded fish also help control mosquito populations. (Photo: Wiki Commons/public domain) Not all college students are created equal when it comes to math proficiency, but surely they're all at least more capable than a fish, right?
Think again. According to National Geographic, common mosquitofish show roughly the same numerical skills as college students in some laboratory tests.
Mosquitofish are tiny but hardy freshwater fish named for their appetite for mosquito larvae. Because they are highly social and seem to monitor the size of their groups, scientists have long suspected that they had at least some basic math proficiency. After a previous study demonstrated that the fish can count, researchers wanted to see how far their math skills could go.
A special experiment was designed in which lone fish were trained to associate a door bearing a certain number of geometric shapes with the path to rejoining a larger group. They were then placed in a tank with two doors, each bearing a symbol representing a different number, and given a choice of swimming through one of them. The fish were motivated to choose based on their natural disposition to prefer larger groups over smaller ones.
The test was designed so that researchers were not only able to identify how well the fish counted, but also how adept they were at differentiating ratios.
The results were surprising. Not only could the fish tell the difference between small numbers such as four and eight, but they could differentiate between quantities as large as 100 and 200.
Scientists learned that not all ratios were as easy for the fish to recognize, however. For instance, the fish differentiated between ratios of 1:2 (8 versus 16) or 2:3 (8 versus 12) with ease, but they struggled when the ratio became 3:4 (9 versus 12). In other words, when the amounts on the doors were closer in number, the fish failed to tell them apart.
But their failure isn't shocking. It turns out that humans also find ratios closer in number more difficult to differentiate.
Imagine walking into a room with two piles of red balls. If you were told one pile had 50 balls and the other pile had 100, then you could probably identify which pile was which with ease. But what if one pile had 50 balls and the other pile had 60? It might be more difficult to see the difference.
Interested in quantifying how the numerical skills of fish compare to those of humans, the researchers decided to perform a similar test on college students.
While the students were universally more accurate than the fish, they showed the same degraded ability to judge number differences as ratios shifted from 2:3 to 3:4. In other words, its not ridiculous to compare the abilities of fish and college students at differentiating ratios.
"You just don't expect interesting results like this when dealing with animals like fish," said study leader Christian Agrillo of the University of Padova in Italy. "We thought this was really incredible."
Whether these results are interpreted as boding well for the fish or poorly for the average college student is left to the discretion of the reader.
Also on MNN: Boy discovers microbe that eats plastic
Comments
Mike
01/14/2011 12:47 PM
The byline "Mosquitofish perform as well as college students on a basic numbers test" is BS because the fact is "...the students were universally more accurate than the fish..." so they didn't do just as well.
Dagda
01/19/2011 14:02 PM
"they showed the SAME [emphasis added] degraded ability to judge number differences as ratios shifted from 2:3 to 3:4."
Steve
01/12/2011 01:22 AM
Now wondering whether these fishes are good or our math skills are bad. Which one is true now ?
Thag
01/11/2011 13:43 PM
One day, Mosquitofish will be our overlords
james
01/11/2011 13:29 PM
Do mosquitofish also perform just as good as MNN writers when it comes to a basic grammar test?
Ken
01/11/2011 13:27 PM
Do they perform just as well as journalists when deciding whether they are using and adjective or an adverb?
Fast Eddie
01/11/2011 01:13 AM
Though it's not been explicitly stated here, one might also surmise that the comparison is even closer among college students who drink like fish.
