• Welcome
  • Community
  • Blogs
  • Photos
  • Videos
  • Join
  • Log in
Follow MNN    
MNN - Mother Nature Network - Envrionmental News
improve your world

 

Friday, May 25, 2012
  • Earth Matters

    Browse All » Animals Weather Energy Politics Space Translating Uncle Sam Wilderness & Resources

  • Health

    Browse All » Allergies Fitness & Well-Being Healthy Spaces

  • Lifestyle

    Browse All » Arts & Culture Travel Natural Beauty & Fashion Recycling Responsible Living

  • GREEN TECH

    Browse All » Computers Gadgets & Electronics Research & Innovations Transportation

  • Eco-Biz & Money

    Browse All » Green Workplace Personal Finance Sustainable Business Practices

  • Food & Drink

    Browse All » Beverages Healthy Eating Recipes

  • Your Home

    Browse All » At Home Organic Farming & Gardening Remodeling & Design

  • family

    Browse All » Babies & Pregnancy Family Activities Pets Protection & Safety

Tweet
Pin It
Email Bookmark and ShareShare
WorldShares lets you earn donations for your favorite nonprofit. Earn up to 20 points now.
Learn More

Earn Points
What's this?
MNN.COM›

MNN BLOGGERS

Shea Gunther

British newspaper blows geoengineering story

The Telegraph carried a story about a plan to shoot solar shields into space and managed to get nearly every fact wrong.

Fri, Feb 27 2009 at 4:31 PM EST

Photo credit: Flickr user Jalaspages

There have been plenty of crazy ideas thrown around over the past few years on how we can combat global warming. Geoengineers have developed elaborate plans to do everything from dumping iron in the oceans to spur the growth of CO2-gobbling plankton to releasing large amounts of sulphur into the air to reflect sunlight back into space to erecting large sun shields in space to keep the suns rays from hitting us in the first place.

The Telegraph (UK) wrote a story about this last idea, putting solar reflectors into space to block solar rays, and managed to completely screw up just about every important detail in the story. The current version of the story (and it could be updated anytime) says that the plan would require $350 trillion and a gun with a barrel .6 miles across to work, numbers putting the plan squarely into the camp of crazy talk.

Those numbers tripped my BS alarm and I placed a call to the scientist behind the plan, University of Arizona professor Roger Angel, to get the real scoop.

Dr. Angel laughed when I told him about the $350 trillion price tag and .6 mile wide gun that the Telegraph reported. His plan would actually require $5 trillion and the gun used to shoot the sun shields into space would only be about a meter wide. $Five trillion is still a lot of money, but if it's spread out over 50 years (the expected lifetime of the sun reflectors), it comes out to $100 billion a year. We have been spending more that much in our stupid war in Iraq every year and all we get out of that is a lot of death and destruction. Dr. Angel's plan would chop off 2 percent of the sun's incoming rays and in the right set of circumstances, could save the world.

Some critics of geoengineering find fault with the use of resources that could better be used to boost our use of renewable energy to cut down on the release of greenhouse gases, a critique that Dr. Angel acknowledges and actually embraces — he is currently working on technology that would boost solar panel output with the use of concentrator lenses.

It's more important to get ourselves weaned off of fossil fuels right now than to work on plans to engineer the globe back a few degrees. At the same time, though, we shouldn't completely abandon visionary (OK, some may say crazy) schemes for quickly cooling the planet. We could find ourselves faced with rapidly rising levels of CO2 (permafrost melts, releasing massive amounts of dormant CO2 which causes more melting, causing more CO2 to be released, rinse and repeat) and having a few good, technically plausible ideas for reacting just as quickly might be a smart idea.

Here's a video from the Telegraph that actually gets everything right and explains the whole thing pretty well. Someone over there needs to get their facts checked and fix the errors in the story.

 

 

 

Previous Post
The Coen Brothers tackle "clean coal"
   Next Post
Here we go again: Weather is not climate
You might also like:

Comments

Follow this conversation
Add your comment
View:
  • All (0)

Add your comment

Sign in with one of these accounts or just add your comment below.
    Log in or
    create an account
     
    •  
Used only for emailed comments and will not be displayed with your post
Notify me with an email when other people comment on this article.
The posting of advertisement, profanity or personal attacks is prohibited.
Click here to review our Terms of Use

EDITORS' PICKS

tease to bigfoot




tease to ketchup

tease to American Idol

ADVERTISEMENT

NEWSLETTER

Mother Nature. Delivered

CONNECT WITH MNN

Follow @twitterapi
 Tumblr
 Google +

About Shea Gunther

Eco-entrepreneur on politics, energy and Earth's resources.

RSS feedMore about Shea

Recent Posts

  • Hawaii bans plastic bags
  • Spring Back Recycling: Saving mattresses from being thrown away while creating jobs
  • Combat juggling: Nerdiest sport ever?
+ Add this to my site

Shea's BLOGROLL

EcorazziEco-Chick
WorldChangingTreehugger
GroovyGreenTriple Pundit
Green DigGreen LA girl
Jetson GreenEcoGeek
Marc GuntherEarth2Tech
Twlight EarthMax Gladwell

ADVERTISEMENT



Quick Links

  • About Us
  • Advisory Board
  • Editors' Blog
  • Press
  • Privacy
  • Sitemap
  • Terms of Service
  • WorldShares

MNN Tools

  • Advice
  • Blogs
  • Day in History
  • Eco-glossary
  • Infographics
  • Lists
  • Photos
  • Videos

Connect

  • Community
  • Contact Us
  • Contests
  • Idea Lab
  • Mixed Greens
  • Newsletters
  • Polls
  • RSS

Channels

  • Earth Matters
  • Health
  • Lifestyle
  • Green Tech
  • Eco-Biz & Money
  • Your Home
  • Family
  • State Reports

Follow MNN

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Tumblr
  • Google+
  • StumbleUpon
 

Copyright © 2012 MNN Holdings, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Website by GLICK INTERACTIVE | Powered by CIRRACORE
 
SPONSORS