Cloud seeding not to blame for Colorado flooding
Scientists have dismissed the internet-based theory due to the physical impossibility of cloud seeding producing the amount of rain Colorado has had.
Tue, Sep 17, 2013 at 02:21 PM
A thunderstorm cloud lingers over the Sports Authority Field at Mile High in Colorado on Sept. 5. (Photo: Doug Pensinger/Getty Images)
Colorado's recent massive flooding, which has left hundreds of people unaccounted for, has been called an anomalous 100- or even 1,000-year event by the scientific community. Such floods have a 1 percent and 0.1 percent chance of occurring, respectively, during any given year. While those odds make them rare events, they are the result of natural larger-scale weather and climate patterns, with perhaps an assist from climate change.
Still, some Internet users have voiced alternative views, suggesting that the destructive rainstorms were more directly human-induced, the result of Colorado's cloud-seeding program.
Cloud seeding, in which tiny silver iodide particles are sprayed into clouds to provide a core for ice crystals to form around, falls within the Colorado Weather Modification Program that is overseen by the Colorado Water Conservation Board and is used primarily by ski resorts to increase the snowpack during the winter. The program — which has been reported to increase the snowpack by 10 to 15 percent each year — remains controversial among those concerned about the unknown repercussions of manipulating weather in this way. [Colorado Flood Photos: 100-Year Storm]
But Andrew Heymsfield, senior research scientist at the National Center for Atmospheric Research in Boulder, Colo., (which was shut down by the floods) says that there is no scientific basis for the argument that cloud seeding could have caused the recent destructive storms.
"You would have to be seeding over massive areas continuously for this to happen," Heymsfield told LiveScience. "You cannot create the precipitation we had by cloud seeding. There is no way that man can do that."
Aside from being physically unfeasible on the scale that the storms occurred, Heymsfield said, cloud seeding in Colorado also takes place predominately in the western part of the state, where the large ski resorts are located. The weather system responsible for the flooding blew northward from the south, further ruling out any association with cloud seeding in the western part of the state, Heymsfield said.
Even if the weather modification program were able to produce the storms that occurred within the past week, they would not be doing so at this time of year, since few, if any, ski resorts have begun cloud seeding this early in the season, Heymsfield said.
Follow Laura Poppick on Twitter. Follow LiveScience on Twitter, Facebook and Google+. Original article on LiveScience.
Related on LiveScience and MNN: