Coal: Jobs should not trump mountains
Thu, Mar 26 2009 at 4:12 PM EST
Photo credit: Flickr user J3Net If you were paying attention to the news this week, you might have seen the headlines popping up stating that the EPA was putting a halt to all permits involving blowing up mountains to get at the sweet, sweet coal inside. The elation that flew through the green blogosphere was short lived however as the EPA quickly clarified that they were in fact looking at only two permits out of the hundred or so up for review.
Of course, the mining industry didn't let that fact get in the way of them freaking out all over themselves saying that the Obama Administration was practically stealing the food out of the mouths of coal miners children. They're claiming that 14,000 jobs are at stake (quick reality check- they're not) if the permits to blow up mountains and dump the debris into miles of streambed aren't approved, post haste.
The debate over mountaintop removal mining should not be about jobs. There's a way bigger issue at play here — we're talking about DESTROYING ENTIRE MOUNTAINS. No job is worth that (and let's ignore the fact that mountaintop removal mining provides fewer jobs than tunnel mining, that's why the industry likes it).
It's easy for me to say that — I don't make a living blowing up mountains. But just as the loggers who made a living cutting down old growth forests had to retool their careers when we started paying attention to that back in the 70s and 80s, todays coal miners will have to do the same. Our fight against coal needs to have two fronts — one where we work on phasing out the most polluting power source on the planet, and another where we retrain the workers left behind in the shift and make sure they come out in a better position than when they worked a mile underground.
When cars came onto the scene there were cries from the horsecare industry about their lost jobs. When movies switched from silent to talkies, piano players were fired all around the country. Many a swordsmith has been displaced by the shift to firearms.
Why does it have to be different for coal miners? Why do they, above all, deserve to cling to their dirty, dangerous jobs?
We need to kill coal and we need to convert the coal workers to green workers. The coal industry is going to be the last group on earth to push for that transition, so they must be pushed back whenever they try to hold the line.
Yesterday was a good day for the fight against mountaintop removal mining — Senators Benjamin L Cardin (D-MD) and Lamar Alexander (R-TN) introduced legislation that would prohibit the dumping of mining waste into streams. This would effectively end mountaintop removal mining.
I love this quote from Mr. Alexander (a Republican said this!?):
Coal is an essential part of our energy future, but it is not necessary to destroy our mountaintops in order to have enough coal,” said Senator Alexander, a member of the Water and Wildlife Subcommittee of the Committee on Environment and Public Works which has jurisdiction over this issue. “Millions of tourists spend tens of millions of dollars in Tennessee every year to enjoy the natural beauty of our mountains — a beauty that, for me, and I believe for most Tennesseans, makes us proud to live here.”
OK, so I disagree with his assertion that coal is an essential part of our energy future, but I give him a lot of credit for seeing the need to preserve mountain ranges.
How bizarre is the world that I give credit to a U.S. senator for realizing blowing up mountains to get at coal is stupid. I feel like I step into the Bizarro World every time I write about this issue.
Alright, I'm climbing down from my rant tower. "The Office" is new tonight.
Are you on Twitter? Follow me (@sheagunther) there, I give good tweets.
Link
EMAIL
Stumble
Tweet
CLOSE
link:
link:
The opinions expressed by MNN Bloggers and those providing comments are theirs alone, and do not reflect
the opinions of MNN.com. While we have reviewed their content to make sure it complies with our Terms and Conditions,
MNN is not responsible for the accuracy of any of their information.
| « Previous Aquafina fails Green Marketing 101 | Next » Tweet-a-watt now available for sale |
Comments(3)
Posted By Anonymous - Sun, Apr 26 2009 at 3:04 PM ESTWe have too many mountains
It seems to me that with the prairies becoming overly dry, it would make sense to remove some of our mountains in order to let the clouds through from the pacific. I think the pacific coasters might be pleased with the results as well, as less rain would fall in their already soggy area. Seems to me to be a win for evryone.
Posted By Uncle B - Thu, Mar 26 2009 at 7:52 PM ESTPoor Dumb Laboring ********
Please tell the fellas, they are better off on welfare, or doing part-time, and living in poverty, but living. I am on permanent disability from the hard-rock mining industry. The "Danger pay" is not worth it! let the f*ckin' new robots like they have in the Inco mine in Sudbury, Ontario get silicosis, let black lung kill off the automated scoop trams. Maybe a computerized radio controlled "Jumbo" drill can get rheumatism and arthritis instead of you. Let the rich ****** at the top of the hole.... More
Miners???
Mining is one of the pollutants in the erath's atmosphere. This has a big contribution of chemical materials which can destroy the environment. Coal mining is known as the cause of global warming which, Algore discussed. So there is no good reason to give miners additional things that they need. What you do outside of work should have nothing whatsoever to do with work, but that would make sense. (Which isn't allowed, just ask Congress.) A late payment is something you want to avoid, even if it.... More