OUT OF TOUCH?: Exxon Mobile CEO Rex Tillerson didn't like being called 'out of touch' by Sen. J. Rockefeller during Thursday's hearing on oil subsidies. (Photo: Zuma Press Inc.)
Thursday morning in Washington began with what has become a yearly ritual. The executives from the big five oil companies got to answer questions about their government subsidies in the wake of huge quarterly profits.
Senate Finance Committee Chariman Max Baucus wanted to know exactly why the "Big Five" felt they should continue to get $4 billion in taxpayer subsidies while enjoying profits of $31 billion during the first quarter of 2011 alone. The executives tried their best to explain it; something that is increasingly harder to do with a Congress that wants to make large reductions to the federal deficit.
Schumer demands to know if education is more important than oil subsidies
Chuck Schmuer put James Mulva, the CEO of ConocoPhillips, in a tough spot when he asked the CEO if he thought pell grants were more important than oil subsidies. Mulva, who just a day earlier said anyone for repealing oil subsidies is “un-American” didn’t directly answer the question. Then Schumer replied, "Do you think people who advocate cutting student aid — are they un-American too? Do you think anyone who advocates cutting these types of subsidies are un-American, yes or no? That one we deserve a yes nor no answer on." The question was answered with neither a yes or a no.
Menendez angry after being called ‘un-American'
While Chuck Schmuer certainly fired the first shots of the hearing, it was Sen. Robert Menendez (D-N.J.) who hit hardest. Menendez, like Schumer, directed his questioning to Mulva. Picking right up where Schumer left off, Menendez first demanded that Mulva apologize. When he didn’t get an apology Menendez said, “The bottom line is you're unwilling to apologize for your company's statement so I will continue to take offense to it." Menendez also was quick to point out that Republicans like former President George W. Bush and current Speaker of the House Rep. John Boehner (R-Ohio) had said that they would support rolling back the government subsidies of oil companies as well.
Jay Rockefeller says the executives are out of touch
The normally mild-mannered West Virginian seemed to have a particular chip on his shoulder when he got the microphone. He continuously told the executives that he thought they were “out of touch with everyday Americans.” Rockefeller (D-W.V.) didn’t stop there. “The whole concept of sharing makes you guys threaten to move to another country," he said. "I don’t buy it. You are all out of touch with the American people.” Rockefeller then took another jab at the executives saying, “You have no idea what your profits really are.” ExxonMobile’s Rex Tillerson struck back saying, “I am not out of touch.” He then said that ExxonMobile didn’t get subsidies, but instead got “legitimate tax incentives.” Late in the hearing, for good measure I suppose, Rockefeller got the microphone and called Tillerman “out of touch” one last time.
Senator Wyden’s incriminating video
Senator Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) should get some credit for bringing in some digital video production to the hearing, though I suppose the oil executives aren’t as keen on the idea. Wyden played a video of the 2005 version of the Big Five who all answered “yes” when asked if they agreed with then-President George W. Bush’s comments that “with oil prices at $55 a barrel oil companies don’t need ‘incentives’ to drill.” After playing the video Wyden said, "You all said you didn't need them in 2005. You seem to be telling a different story today.” Since the Big Five executives appearance in 2005, the price of oil has essentially doubled. Here’s the Wyden video:
Crapo shows up late, after meeting with BP lobbyist
You got to hand it to Sen. Mike Crapo (R-Idaho), who doesn’t let a good lobbying visit get in the way of a congressional hearing. Crapo showed up to Thursday’s hearing about an hour late after spending his morning at a fundraiser with none other than BP executive Lamar McKay. One of the event hosts was Aleix Jarvis, a lobbyist for D.C. powerhouse Fierce, Isakowitz & Blalock. Jarvis represents BP for the firm, according to data from the Center for Responsive Politics. So far this year, BP has paid the firm $60,000. When Crapo did show up and get to a microphone, he first asked that the oil companies represented at the hearing be referred to as “energy companies.” He then asked each executive, starting with McKay, to talk about how green they are.
On a regular day on Capitol Hill any of these events would have been headline worthy. Instead we got all of them in one place at one time. Sen. Robert Menendez is expected to introduce a bill in the coming weeks that calls for repealing the oil subsidies, once and for all. Menendez’s bill is not expected to get the necessary 60 votes to make it out of the Senate. But, for the first time in decades, the oil subsidies appear to be very vulnerable to getting rolled back.
Not only did senators vow to bring back Menendez’s bill if it fails to pass, but a recent poll shows that 74 percent of Americans favor eliminating the subsidies. That’s a big number. When do you remember the last time 74 percent of Americans felt the same way about anything?
The opinions expressed by MNN Bloggers and those providing comments are theirs alone, and do not reflect the opinions of MNN.com. While we have reviewed their content to make sure it complies with our Terms and Conditions, MNN is not responsible for the accuracy of any of their information.