Are fireworks bad for the environment?
Fireworks can unleash a shower of toxins into soil and water, and scientists are only beginning to figure out what that means for human health.
Perchlorates and particulates
But a 2007 study of an Oklahoma lake following fireworks displays overhead found that perchlorate levels spiked more than 1,000 times above the baseline level for 14 hours after a show. While the maximum concentration detected was 44.2 micrograms — less than 1 milligram — per liter, the study was still the most concrete evidence yet that fireworks release perchlorates into waterways.
• Strontium (red): This soft, silvery-yellow metal turns red when it burns, is extremely reactive with both air and water, and can be radioactive. Some strontium compounds dissolve in water, and others move deep into soil and groundwater; radioactive strontium has a half-life of 29 years. While low levels of stable and radioactive strontium haven't been shown to affect human health, they both can be dangerous at high doses. Radioactive strontium can damage bone marrow, cause anemia and prevent blood from clotting correctly, and lab studies have shown it can lead to birth defects in animals. Stable strontium is mainly a threat to children because it can impair their bone growth.
• Aluminum (white): Since aluminum is the most abundant metal in Earth's crust — and one of humanity's most widely used — avoiding exposure is almost impossible. Virtually all food, water, air and soil contain some amount of aluminum — the average adult eats about 7 to 9 milligrams of the silvery-white metal every day in food. It's generally safe at these levels, but it can affect the brain and lungs at higher concentrations. People and animals exposed to large amounts of aluminum have performed poorly on mental and physical tests, and some studies suggest aluminum exposure may lead to Alzheimer's disease, although that connection has yet to be proven.
• Copper (blue): Fireworks' blue hues are produced by copper compounds. These aren't very toxic on their own, but the copper jump-starts the formation of dioxins when perchlorates in the fireworks burn. Dioxins are vicious chemicals that don't occur naturally and aren't intentionally produced anywhere; they only exist as unwelcome byproducts of certain chemical reactions, one of which happens in blue fireworks. The most noted health effect of dioxin exposure is chloracne, a severe skin disease with acne-like lesions mostly on the face and upper body. Dioxin doesn't stop there, though — the World Health Organization has identified it as a human carcinogen, and it's also been shown to disrupt hormone production and glucose metabolism.
• Barium (green): Fish and other aquatic organisms can accumulate barium, which means it can move up the food chain. The silvery-white metal naturally bonds with other elements to form a variety of compounds that all have different effects — none are known to be carcinogenic, but they can cause gastrointestinal problems and muscular weakness when exposure exceeds EPA drinking water standards. Symptoms may include vomiting, diarrhea, breathing trouble, changes in blood pressure, numbness around the face, general muscle weakness and cramps. High levels of barium exposure can lead to changes in heart rhythm, paralysis or death.
• Rubidium (purple): This soft, silvery metal is one of the most abundant elements on Earth. It burns purple, melts to a liquid at 104 degrees Fahrenheit and is highly reactive with water, capable of igniting fires even far below the freezing point. It hasn't been reported to cause any major environmental damage, but it can cause skin irritation since it's so reactive with moisture, and it's moderately toxic when ingested, reportedly able to replace calcium in bones (PDF).
- Ask Vanessa: Do fireworks harm the environment?
- Greening your Memorial Day BBQ
- Eco-fun for Memorial Day
- July 4th: Precautions for pets
- 4 eco-crafts or July 4
- Green your Labor Day weekend
- National Labor Day Eat-In
- Fun, Earth-friendly family activities for summer
- 20 ways for renters to stay cool and save money this summer
- What causes lightning?
WorldShares
lets you earn donations for your favorite nonprofit. Earn up to 20
points now.Learn More Earn Points
|
link:
Comments
Where I live, even though fireworks are illegal to own, they are set off every night for 3 months. They're bad for the environment, keep working adults awake, wake up screaming babies, set fire to things, & terrify animals.
it's funny cause there is danger on different levels, and of course none of the local or state govs can really fund this stuff without going into more debt, but they just wave the flag and take the country into greater ruin.
The one that burns me is that the patriots who have any common sense are called tree huggers, or some other stupid term just because they want to preserve the country.
Does it really matter----HELL NO, let's just ACT patriotic while the country falls apart!.... More
Fireworks are made with American money at Chinese bullet factories
Yes it's true, America and the western world will spend hundreds of millions of dollars this and every year, even during the recession, for poisonous chemical fireworks made at the gunpowder factories in china.
These same factories are expanding with our American fireworks dollars and one day may be making bullets to kill our children and grandchildren.
How foolish can we be? Have we become so fat.... More
no hablo ingles, no comprende???????
fireworks are a danger to all you haters.
hello i am varsha frm usa i am a indian but i live in usa i wanna to say that fireworks are good to ligt up the sky and its makes the sky beautifull to but it cn harm us if we dont burn them carefully and it can harm to animals to
hello just to let you guys know that fireworks are very dangers it could hurt someone really bad and its is also bad for the environmental because all the sparks can fall in to the water which mean it could do a lot of damage to the water which can cause a lot of harm and all the firework box would be left on the ground which can led to trash being on the floor which isn't good at all i know it for 4th of july i get it that you guys wanna be able to see thing shoot up in the sky but im just.... More
hello just to let you guys know that fireworks are very dangers it could hurt someone really bad and its is also bad for the environmental because all the sparks can fall in to the water which mean it could do a lot of damage to the water which can cause a lot of harm and all the firework box would be left on the ground which can led to trash being on the floor which isn't good at all i know it for 4th of july i get it that you guys wanna be able to see thing shoot up in the sky but im just.... More
Local Line LLC is specialised in providing Services and supplies to oil and gas sectors. Supplies different types of chemicals used in oil sectors in the Middle East and around the world.
I recently did some research on this matter and came up with the conclusion that we aren't exactly sure how harmful fireworks are to the environment or people. It is important, however, to at least consider that chemicals are used in fireworks and that other options need to be researched/considered. The point is that most people don't consider these types of matters.
Here is an article I posted about fireworks found in nature. I think it's worth looking at. .... More
1. "Just One Night of Fun"--are you not paying attention? Pro fireworks go off not only at Independence Day celebrations, but Labor Day, Memorial Day, every time a pro baseball team wins a home game, every time a pro baseballer hits a home run, at pro wrestling shows, monster truck rallies, etc. etc. Amateur shows go on for around two weeks before and after independence day, on all the other occasions noted above, and also Easter and Christmas in South Carolina.
2. Anyone who.... More
I agree with most of what you're saying and yes littering the beaches with lots of fireworks debris is bad for that environment but I really think that saying that it is 'just as bad' as the BP oil spill is absolutely crazy. The ramifications of the oil spill on the future of the ocean is massive. There are so many species being affected by this and I really just don't think it's in any way comparable.
While the the pollution of our water is important, I am also bothered and assaulted by the explosive bombardment of noise. Where we are, in a summer community in Goshen, MA some folks think we all enjoy their destruction of peace & quiet. And, unfortunately, it's not only on the 4th. Besides, these private disturbances are also illegal, I'm told.
I think the effects are serious resulting from fireworks, but come on, it's an American tradition. It's the way of life and celebrating that for ONE mere evening is a necessity for tradition.
In short, it's hard to believe that there are folks who are willing to look the other way simply because of human-created tradition. What about all the other equally-important species that live here who do not have a voice in environmentalism (or non)? Why should humans continue to ruin the habitability of the Earth simply out of enjoyment sake? It's very disheartening that we (as a whole) let greed and selfishness lead the way for our future, or lack of if we continue on the track we're.... More
Green Movement Calls Fireworks 'Eco-Hazards,' Sues to Ban July 4th Display in California
http://newsbusters.org/blogs/alana-goodman/2010/06/29/green-movement-cal...
Green Movement Calls Fireworks 'Eco-Hazards,' Sues to Ban July 4th Display in California
http://newsbusters.org/blogs/alana-goodman/2010/06/29/green-movement-cal...
I think that I will select a few big used tires from my enormous stack and burn them sequentially on the 4th - it should make a nice black smoke that can be seen fro miles. Saw them burning in Iraq and Afghanistan when I was there...I think they will display nicely here too. Perhaps when the liberals stop their fanatic "hate-everything-about-America" agenda...I won't have to burn tires anymore.
It's amazing to see these types of comments. Whether or not it's a true claim that tire-burning will really happen here, it's irritating to see the close-mindedness of the individuals who feel it necessary to take a stance against improving our existence here. That's what all the protest is all about - it's about stopping the destructive nature of the human species so that Mother Earth may be able to sustain life for all living beings, not just for humans. It's possible to exist in harmony.... More
The only dangers of Fireworks is that environmentalist nut jobs like the one that wrote the article aren't attached to them when launched. Enough Said.
dude your stupid you just dont realized the real dangers of these magnificint thing. even though i love fireworks i think we should use more environmentally friendly things like laser light shows. i know they dont sound as exciting but they can be.
Enter your comments here Is the amazing amount of PLASTIC debris, partly melted, that washes ashore with the high tide after every fireworks display let alone the chunks of cardboard/paper mortars that float in that supposingly "desinegrate" when exploded. Every day when we walk along the shores in Mission Bay, San Diego with our dog, you can expect to find firework debris at the high mark year round even if there hasn't been a display set off in months! This is why FIREWORKS ARE BAD FOR THE.... More
i went to the fire works sat on the sand semi close to where they where shot off and i got sick the same way 2 years. the first year i thought food poisoning but the 2nd. year the same way no way it was the fire works by the time i drove home got in the yard i could not hold my head up i had to be helped in and i threw up was very sick and disy until the next day this happened 2 years in a row i had forgotten the first year until it happened the 2nd year so no more close fire works for me and.... More
I really enjoyed the video. What a call to wake up about fireworks! Thanks you! I started to do some searching and came across http://www.backcountryattitude.com/toxic_fireworks.html which was also helpful in my research. I'm gonna tell everyone I know!
i was searching for how harmful are fireworks for the enviornment becauase i was not sure if they are. this article tells me that they are and the various comments as usual are for and against it ... what i am a bit confused about is that i didn't see anyone (including the article itself) mention about simple air-pollution. the emission of CO2 in the air. isn't that in itself a reason not to burn them? no matter how small, air pollution is air pollution, right?
Compared to, say, even a small commercial jet flight, the amount of greenhouse gas emissions from a fireworks display is pretty small. Considering the thousands who delight in such events, it's a minor consideration. Minimizing air- and water-borne pollutants is by far the bigger issue.
It's any and all polluting factors that have to be considered. The more that can be removed from the waste/pollution stream, the closer we can be to having a sustainable existence with all the other life-forms that we share the Earth with. Just because one polluting activity appears to be minimal compared to another, it doesn't make it ok to perform these acts - it's merely a self-justified distortion of reality. Please wake up and realize that we aren't the "owners" of this planet and it's.... More
Want to wow your neighbors this Saturday with some bright and cheery Fourth of July trvia? Tell them about the dangers of perchlorate, the molecule that helps fireworks burn longer. According to experts at debit cards Systems who study explosive materials, the molecules are not only harmful to the environment, but to humans as well–-and repeated exposure poses health risks.
The good news is that scientists
One thing I always think about on the 4th is how much bangs and flashes of light going on across the country would disturb wildlife. I know a lightning storm is a somewhat similar thing, but...?
I don't think your health argument is too strong because you don't mention how people ingest these chemicals. Also, you say "high doses," but how high is "high?" Show danger levels compared to actual levels supposedly ingested by people as a result of firework debris.
I was watching our local fireworks display last evening and, as I watched large clouds of smoke move downwind, couldn't help but questions the environmental affect of this long held and loved practice.
Your article was just what I needed and the post commentary was also entertaining as well as educational. The bottom line appears to be that we just don't know the extent of the effects. If you consider that thousands of communities are using this practice across the US in one evening, not.... More
I'm hypothyroid (hashimotos- my immune system decided to destroy my thyroid), and, call me stupid, but I don't think fireworks caused it. I think, if I was to go searching for why I'm hypothyroid, I would start with my grandmother. Who was also hypothyroid. I also have asthma. Guess what? My father, grandfather, and 4 aunts and uncles also have asthma. Funny how genetics works. Not to say environment and genetics do not have a decent amount of interplay- it's just overly simplistic to.... More
For generations my maternal side of the family has ran a fireworks warehouse. My mom worked there as a teen and continues to run stands on the 4th. She just had to have her thyroid removed because it was cancerous. My great-grandma died of thyroid cancer. I have worked the warehouse in the June July months every year from age 10-20years old. I am now 26 and have an enlarged thyroid. Haven't had the ultrasound yet but it may be cancerous as well. I spent years breathing in gunpowder and metals..... More
I will clarify that my personal health care proffessionals and my own research is convincing of the harm of gunpowder ingestion. I do not think the occassional 4th celebration will be detrimental only chronic exposure. I wish I could find info on other fireworks warehouse workers health. Women seem more prone to the thyroid problems caused by toxins. Also I have anemia which can be a side effect of exposure but it is off and on. I believe the toxins are preventing my throid from absorbing.... More
The major risk of fireworks, as any ER doc knows, is children playing with the fireworks and getting severe burns. Even if fireworks are not legal in their state, many families have purchased these items out of state and brought them home.
Lets not pretend that fireworks are safe. We all know better.
Had no idea so many people who don't give a crap or even believe in climate change are reading MNN and spend their time trying to attack a writer for discussing POSSIBLE environmental damage. You guys need a hobby, for real...
All those who are yelling at the writer, you must not have done your research. A Biochemist would know what kind of effect these chemicals have on one's body. Common sense tells us that these fireworks are all made with chemicals, and chemicals are not good for you (period).
Those laser fire works as an alternative look good but one needs to study if there is any harm from them, just in case.
Sitting in bumper to bumper traffic also causes us to breathe exhaust fumes, burning.... More
Several points:
1) Rubidium is never used in fireworks. And, it is not "one of the most abundent elements on earth". Rather, it's about the 23rd most abundant. Finally, it's flame color is not purple, but red. Purple (a difficult fireworks color) is produced by using a carefully balanced mixture of strontium and copper compounds.
2) Cadmium, likewise, has no use in fireworks.
3) Your mention on "radioactive" strontium is entirely spurious to a discussion of fireworks.... More
Here in Gualala Ca, The almighty CCC shut down our firworks show after our 2007 show, claiming distubance of birds 1.4 miles from the firing point in another county! their extremest leader (Birdman of Sea Ranch) built his home for 2 years as close to the island where these birds live as possible. I suppose Back Hoes, Hammers, Heavy Equipment,Nail Guns ect. didn't bother these birds? Hipocrats!
I can't wait untilt he story breaks on the true effects of perchlorate on our nation. It moves 30:1 over iodine and concentrates in the breast milk. It is effecting all infants and children in Our Nation. It's in the food. Look at the Colorado River and the Imperial Valley. 0.5 ppb is recommended in water. The EPA is saying 24 ppb is ok. What about the 1,500 ppb in the tomatoes? The watermelons? The spinach? The FDA knows about the problem. When are we as a nation going to begin talking about it?.... More
thee have ben many studies on this subject: Monterey Bay Marine Sanctuary did a 12 year study, and disneyland did a study of the lake where fireworks were detonated for 10 years EVERY NIGHT.
This Article is full of lies and speculation and NO SCIENCE
Cadmium and rubidium compounds are never used in commercial fireworks.
Your "research" obviously involved participating in on-line chat groups of teenagers who "know" all about how to make big booms.
I make fireworks for a living. Cadmium and rubidium compounds are NEVER used for coloring fireworks.
Also --
Disney did NOT employ the air-lift system for the reason of "limiting particulates". They employed it to improve the visuals at ground level, that can be.... More
"some studies suggest aluminum exposure may lead to Alzheimer's disease, although that connection has yet to be proven"
Since when has proof ever been required by the environmentalist agenda? There's no proof that perchlorates from fireworks have caused any thyroid problems in humans, but that doesn't keep you green weenies from crying about it. There's no proof of man made global warming either, but that hasn't stopped you idiots from making scare mongering movies and badgering.... More
"There's no proof of man made global warming..."
Show me proof there is not proof. Folks like you are like arguing with religious zealots; constantly arguing against and pleading lack of proof when you yourself have nothing to stand on.
Perhaps you should read scientific periodicals and/or research papers which have the proof you suggest does not exist. And, these papers are written by people who spend many many years actually studying the subject. Instead what you do is spend a.... More
The author of this article clearly knows very little about what he is writting. Rubidium and Cadmium are NOT used in ANY fireworks compositions, PERIOD. This and much other information in this article are typical of the junk science propagated by environmentalists when they latch onto something they just FEEL isn't good for the environment regardless of what the FACTS are. Disney has done studies of the bogus perchorate claims in its lakes over which fireworks are fired EVERY SINGLE NIGHT.... More
Check out Pyrotechnics for the Planet by Bethany Halford in the June 30, 2008 edition of Chemical & Engineering News: http://pubs.acs.org/cen/coverstory/86/8626cover.html. In case anyone questions that scientists do take the notion of greening fireworks seriously.
The information presented in this "news" article is simply untrue, and is nothing more than scare-mongering by someone who is clearly biased against fireworks, and woefully or deliberately ignorant of their chemical composition.
Radioactive?!?! No. Never.
Toxic?!? Everything found under your kitchen sink, or in your garage, is "toxic".
He then goes on to compare fireworks "pollution" to mercury and DDT pollution. Disingenuous at best, and deliberately misleading at.... More
"Toxic?!? Everything found under your kitchen sink, or in your garage, is 'toxic.'"
...Which is probably true for you, and brings up another good point: They don't have to be! There are alternatives that aren't. And only a fool would buy the ones which are unsafe, as only a fool would find bright explosions truly entertaining. Fireworks...boring and poisonous! Made for the cheap little masses who are impressed with cheap little things... You know who you are!!!



























