42 tons of poison to be dumped on island to eradicate rats
In a radical move to eliminate pests and save local wildlife, pristine Lord Howe Island will be blitzed from the air with poison.
E-RAT-ICATION: Invasive black rats could cause the extinction of most of Lord Howe Island's native species if they are not eradicated. (Photo: Vermin Inc/Flickr)
WorldShares
lets you earn donations for your favorite nonprofit. Earn up to 20
points now.Learn More Earn Points
|
link:
Comments
Its this type of poor journalism that gives scientists a bad rap. Its NOT 42 tons of poison, it IS 42 tons of bait which will include 840 GRAMS of poison. Mr. Nelson practiced poor journalism to paint an untrue image of indiscriminate spraying. Check your facts Mr. Nelson read the plan yourself at .... More
Glad you cleared that up. I was thinking they had gone a little nutty over there. I wouldn't my kids, animals or all island creatures to be bombarded with 42 tons of air poison. (Although, I'm pretty sure if I lived there we would take a little 3 day vacation anyway as the stuff fell.)
....please let the experts determine the best solution to a serious, pending environmental disaster!
May I also call your attention to a rat eradication right here in the high and mighty US of A - a Channel Island. (see link, below)
The LHI board has carefully reviewed that success story in planning for their own rat eradication. I wish them much success and hope that it will help them keep their Unesco World Heritage Site designation.
.... More
There has to be another solution, this is negligent destruction, an easy way.
Food and other goods must come into the island by ship. How will this plan prevent the island from being re-infested by the first fertile pair of wharf rats to hit their shores after the poison goes stale?
What about all the plants and habitation. If this chemical messes up the plants then they die or could die and then the whole vegetation will be affected and could effect the growth of plants in that habitat. Insects are one. What kind of damn poison are they talking about. **** it still on earth let the population of rats deal with themselves. What about the air. Thats like years of carbon monixide build up in atlanta all at one time. I sure hope this **** doesn't effect the atsmophere. That .... More
The idea is so bad on so many levels it's unconscionable. The cats, the bounty and shooting at night with night vision goggles would be far better,
Also this article is a bit misleading as it makes it sound like they'll be just spraying poison all over the place. The poison is actually placed in traps that are dropped in a grid pattern over the island. Of course, rats that escape the traps before death will be hazardous to any dog that eats them, but the island has a leash law.
The poison's the best way. Lord Howe has had a bounty on rats since the 1920's. People catch them like crazy but it hasn't made a dent as most of the island is extremely rugged and inaccessible.
Cats were a bigger threat than the rats and have been eradicated from the island. On LHI the cats liked to eat all the ground nesting birds and devastated the birds leaving the harder to catch rats happily multiplying.
The muzzles are to keep the local dogs from eating any dead rats by the.... More
I don't like killing critters without a good reason but there are 2 things that always need to die,bugs and rats. I hope this experiment works so well they do it everywhere in the world that's infested. The only live rats in the whole world should be in laboratories waiting to be cut to pieces.
It would be significantly better to take spayed and neutered cats from animal shelters, implant tracking chips, then set them free for a while. Because they cannot breed and can easily be tracked down and collected afterwards the problem can be resolved without potentially significant health and environmental ramifications. How can you know a species of creature might not become extinct -- rare insects, perhaps -- or that the people living in the area might not accidentally be effected by the.... More
"42 Tons of Poison Dropped on Inhabited Island to Kill Rats...
To protect local wildlife, entire populations of native birds will be caught and kept in cages for 100 days for their own protection. All cows and chickens will be slaughtered or shipped to the mainland, while dog owners will be offered muzzles for their pets, and parents will be advised to keep a close eye on their children."
Are there people on the island or not? And why would you muzzle dog owners, and not the dogs.... More
I think that reads just right. I'm not sure what you are taking from it, but the wording is perfectly fine.
Bring in the cats. Populate the Island with 1000's of farm cats, that'll get rid of em. Then when the cat population gets out of hand bring in the dogs. Then the cougars. Then the cougars will naturally die off because there wont be enough young men to go around.
So they are going to kill all the native insects as well? Sounds like these people are on drugs. What a dumb idea.
Pay $3 per rat that people catch and kill..and as the rat population dwindles up the ante. I guarantee they will hunt them down and kill them all
And then I would move to the island, and breed the freaking rats, to turn in as wild rats that I caught, so as to get a large reward. That won't work, now will it?
A bounty on rats is THE brightest and most sensible idea yet!! Can you believe college educated folks cannot come to this solution, themselves??? What peabrained idiots are in charge?? God help us all....
Please I urge tyou to read on this issue and how successful eradicatyions have been before opening your mount - or using your fingers to write this rubbish!!. Leave this to people who understand what needs to be done rather than coming up with suggestions that WILL NOT ERADICATE (not control - read up on the difference!!) rodents.
this a great first step, but does not go far enough. this island is too important to let ANY species threaten it. they should be dropping much more poisonous chemicals, more frequently, and without giving anyone any protection. then they will have the completely sterile wasteland which they so desire.
*and no people would ever be allowed back. EVAR
Again, please think before you type - this is another example of online garbage - educate yourself and read the Plan and the references contained within it!
I think its a good idea to rid the island of the didease carrying pests
Must be a better way to trap the rats, by fermones or something, then bio-gas the corpses into compressible bottled gas and top soil building sludge, and a fertilizing effluent free of poisons? Straight-forward poisoning seems to simplistic, but possibly the fastest solution. Who or what will deal with all the decaying, and poisonous rat corpses? Seems a shame to waste a potentially valuable resource flow? Even China grows algae in sewage ponds to feed the Carp they sell to American markets..... More
"Straight-forward poisoning seems to simplistic"
seems TOO simplistic
It's three letters, people. Pathetic.
while I can see the need for getting the rat population stopped .. Why not you sterilization.How in the world do you capture the birds? and other wild life.? And what about the shock tho their systems being in cages?
And one very important population HUMANS. This is not a good plan.
READ the Plan - again do not type before you understand. Considerable effort has been expended in preparing the Plan utilising world best practice - including risk assessment and management



























