Members of a bachelor party at Elephant Butte Lake in New Mexico recently stumbled upon an item sticking a few inches out of the ground. As the men dug around it, they discovered a large tusk, which they suspected might belong to a woolly mammoth.

They sent photos to the New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science. Paleontologists think the tusk belongs to a prehistoric elephant known as a Stegomastodon.

Related on MNN: 10 animals presumed extinct in the last decade