Advice | Community | State Reports | Videos | Photos | Blogs
Join | Login
› improve your world
Monday, March 22, 2010
  • Earth Matters

    Browse All » Climate Change Energy Politics Recycling Space Translating Uncle Sam Wilderness & Resources

  • Lifestyle

    Browse All » Arts & Culture Eco-Tourism Health & Well-being Natural Beauty & Fashion Outdoor Activities Pets & Animals Responsible Living

  • GREEN TECH

    Browse All » Computers Gadgets & Electronics Research & Innovations

  • Eco-Biz

    Browse All » Building, Products, Supplies Money & Green Jobs Sustainable Business Practices

  • food

    Browse All » Beer Healthy Eating & Recipes Organic Farming Wine & Spirits

  • Your Home

    Browse All » Around the House Green Building & Remodeling

  • Transportation

    Browse All » Alternative Transportation Cars

  • family

    Browse All » Raising a Family

MNN.COM›MNN BLOGGERS›

Jenn Savedge's Blog

Jenn Savedge

How organic is organic baby formula?

Synthetic ingredients are the norm in today's organic formulas.
Tue, Jul 07 2009 at 2:00 PM EST
Read more: GREEN KIDS, RAISING HEALTHY KIDS

A recent article in the Washington Post raised concerns over the integrity of the organic label on foods today ... particularly as it relates to infant baby formula. According to the article, when the staff at the U.S. Department of Agriculture reviewed the organic certification of infant baby formula, they determined that synthetic additives in organic baby formula violated federal standards and should be banned from a product carrying the federal organic label. Yet today, those same additives can be found in 90 percent of organic baby formula.
 
The additives in question are DHA and ARA, two synthetic fatty acids that some studies suggest can help a baby's neural development. But according to USDA records, when the issue of including these synthetics in organic infant formulas came before the agency in 2006, staff members concluded that the fatty acids could not be added to organic baby formula because they are synthetics that are not on the standards board's approved list.
 
But according to the Post article, this decision was overruled by Barbara Robinson, a deputy USDA administrator who administers the agency's organics program.  Apparently, Robinson made this decision after a telephone call and an e-mail exchange with William J. Friedman, a lawyer who represents the formula makers, claiming in an interview that she agreed with Friedman's argument that fatty acids were not permitted because of an "oversight."
 
However many organic advocates (myself included) beg to differ.  The fatty acids (DHA and ARA) in baby formula are often produced using a potential neurotoxin known as hexane.  That's likley one of the reasons that these two synthetics never made the OK list.  And isn't the whole point of the organic certification to assure consumers that unapproved synthetics are not allowed in products bearing the organic label?  If that's no longer the case, then I guess that black and white USDA certified organic label is no longer as black and white as it appears to be.  
 
 
Photo: rrss
  • Comments (20)
  • Link
  • EMAIL
  • Bookmark and Share
  • RSS
  • Stumble Stumble
  • Tweet Tweet
CLOSE link:
The opinions expressed by MNN Bloggers and those providing comments are theirs alone, and do not reflect the opinions of MNN.com. While we have reviewed their content to make sure it complies with our Terms and Conditions, MNN is not responsible for the accuracy of any of their information.
« Previous
Make your own jump rope
   Next »
Toddler tips: Green your little bean

Comments(20)

  • ALL COMMENTS
  • READERS' SELECTIONS
  • POST A COMMENT
Sort by:
Posted By Anonymous - Sat, Jul 18 2009 at 2:06 PM EST

The BEST organic baby's formula without using hexane

I've done my research and found that Nature's One Baby's Only Organic Formula is the BEST product out there. It's readily available in the US, but in Canada, I've only been able to find one company selling it and I thank them dearly for it! Their service is impeccable and their pricing is very good too! You can find them online at www.ilife.ca.

  • reply
Posted By Anonymous - Wed, Aug 12 2009 at 10:11 PM EST

In Re: to Nature Ones' Organic formula...

I would agree on the company/brand, however, they only have "Toddler" products and do not have an "Infant" formula!

  • reply
Posted By Anonymous - Fri, Aug 28 2009 at 8:10 AM EST

Nature's One does have an Infant line...

I was just on their website looking at formulas for my next baby, You can even order direct from their website single cans or by the case. Their baby formula is called Baby's Only.

http://naturesonedirect.com/

  • reply
Posted By Anonymous - Mon, Sep 14 2009 at 1:21 PM EST

Infant or toddler formula?

I went to the Nature's One website and could not find a formula for infants. All of the "Baby's One" formulas were labeled "Toddler Formula" at the top of the can. I have emailed them to ask specifically if they have infant formulas. I will post their reply.

  • reply
Posted By Daniel - Wed, Nov 18 2009 at 10:46 AM EST

Toddler formula still safe for Infants

Hi there, just letting you know that the toddler formula is still safe for infants to consume. If you check the formulation of the Baby's Only product (e.g. dairy), it's relatively close in nutrient value compared to human milk. However, nothing really compares to mother's milk, but Nature's One Baby's Only is definitely a close second! The only reason it says "toddler formula" is because they want to promote breast feeding as a first choice for feeding baby. But we all know that there.... More

  • reply
Posted By Anonymous - Mon, Jul 13 2009 at 6:30 PM EST

No Hexane DHA in Baby's Only Organic formula

Hexane is the issue. It's poison. Look at all the controversy surrounding BPA. That is found in miniscule amounts in baby products and government demanded it be taken out. Just Bing .

  • reply
Posted By Anonymous - Thu, Jul 09 2009 at 10:13 AM EST

beneficial?

TommyB - Can you please explain to us how DHA and ARA are beneficial to babies? (I'm not being an instigator, I sincerely just don't know)

Thank you.

  • reply
Posted By MIKE PESCATORE - Sat, Oct 24 2009 at 12:05 PM EST

Messin with lipid bi-layers

I will answer for Tommy.He doesn't know nor do the infant formula companies.The scientific research to date does not fully understand the mechanisms involved with DHA/ARA metabolism.These long chain polyunsaturated fatty acids are powerful enough to affect brain and eye development.They work in concert with other fatty acids which make up lipid bi-layers.These lipid bi-layers are found in every cell in the human body.They regulate proteins involved with signaling.The regulation and balance of.... More

  • reply
Posted By Charlotte Vallaeys - Wed, Jul 15 2009 at 8:51 AM EST

DHA

Since DHA and ARA naturally occur in breast milk and are found in brain and eye tissue, some scientists claim that synthetic sources of these fatty acids, when added to formula, benefit infant brain and eye development. However, the vast majority of well conducted clinical trials have found no differences in infant development (cognitive, visual, or neurodevelopmental) between groups of infants given formula with DHA and formula without DHA. A review of existing scientific data on this topic.... More

  • reply
Posted By MIKE PESCATORE - Sat, Oct 24 2009 at 12:20 PM EST

Still researching

Hey Charlotte
Its been a long time since we spoke.I have continued my research and found a link between digestive issues and DHA/ARA supplementation.You can contact me anytime if you are interested.Keep up the good work.
Mike

  • reply
Posted By TommyB - Wed, Jul 08 2009 at 3:18 PM EST

This article is horribly misleading

I am an Environmental Scientist - educated with graduate level Chemistry and Toxicology. The Hexane while dangerous to workers who might be exposed at a plant (under unusual emergency conditions) is not part of the final product, nor would be likely to even exist as residue in the product because of it's extreme volitility.

DHA and ARA are extracted from natural sources and are incredibly beneficial to babys. People need to think for themselves, but more importantly authors and.... More

  • reply
Posted By MIKE PESCATORE - Sat, Oct 24 2009 at 11:19 AM EST

beneficial for who?

Why is DHA incredibly beneficial?It is for infant formula shareholders.It isn't for male infants.In fact the only solid evidence of being beneficial comes from studies conducted by infant formula manufacturers.Independent researchers have failed to find a consistant benefit after millions of infants have consumed these novel oils.The manufacturer of the DHA/ARA can't find a benefit for male infants or a reason for this gender difference.The safety of these oils has been confirmed from.... More

  • reply
Posted By MIKE PESCATORE - Wed, Oct 21 2009 at 4:24 PM EST

DHA/ARA UNSAFE

dON'T WORRY ABOUT THE HEXANE PROCCESSING.Increasing DHA/ARA levels in lipid rafts=increasing lipid raft unsaturation.This will drive needed cholesterol out as well as proteins critical for neuronal development.Affects neuron migration,axon pathfinding,glutamate receptor regulation,neurite outgrowth and synapse formation.Check out www.autisminfantformula.com

  • reply
Posted By MIKE PESCATORE - Wed, Oct 21 2009 at 4:23 PM EST

DHA/ARA UNSAFE

dON'T WORRY ABOUT THE HEXANE PROCCESSING.Increasing DHA/ARA levels in lipid rafts=increasing lipid raft unsaturation.This will drive needed cholesterol out as well as proteins critical for neuronal development.Affects neuron migration,axon pathfinding,glutamate receptor regulation,neurite outgrowth and synapse formation.Check out www.autisminfantformula.com

  • reply
Posted By Anonymous - Tue, Aug 25 2009 at 2:56 PM EST

learn to spell

If you are truly educated with a graduate level Chemistry and Toxicology degree, why can't you spell the plural of "baby" correctly?

  • reply
Posted By Anonymous - Wed, Aug 12 2009 at 10:19 PM EST

RE: misleading??? or are you misinformed?

obviously haxane and other "production chemicals" like malamine are ending up in the "End Product" if they are Testing Positive for them...Hello!

and if the DHA and ARA in the formula's were naturally derived from 'natural sources' it wouldnt be a problem. But the manufacturers are using harmful synthetic versions!

I would assume that you are under the belief of what you have been "taught" and not what is actually truth... its as bad as medical training...doctors are 'taught".... More

  • reply
Posted By Anonymous - Thu, Jul 09 2009 at 10:17 AM EST

Not misleading at all

The original author disputed calling the food organic because it was including SYNTHETIC ingredients produced in a laboratory. That's the issue.

  • reply
Posted By Anonymous - Tue, Jul 07 2009 at 11:23 PM EST

Hexane- it's a trade off

I asked Earth's Best about their extraction process and using hexane. Yes, the do use it, but the amounts in the end product are minimal. Baby formula also has BPA in the can lining. It seems everything probably has some chemical in it, even the rain that comes on to your organic garden. So, it's all a trade off, and an unfortunate consequence of our industrialized world. I like when the organic products list what is organic and what isn't- then we can decide on our own.

  • reply
Posted By Daniel - Wed, Nov 18 2009 at 10:52 AM EST

BPA not in the lining of Nature's One canisters

Please note that there is no BPA in the can lining on Nature's One products or lids. There is, however, a minimal amount in the "easy open" metal top lining which, for the most part, has minimal contact with the product itself. http://www.naturesone.com/dairy/frequent-questions

  • reply
Posted By Maggie - Tue, Jul 07 2009 at 8:20 PM EST

Hexane - not in the end product

The whole hexane issue is moot to many "officials" because while the DHA is extracted from algae using hexane, hexane itself is not in the end product. This is a fine line but one that I am appalled at. About a year ago I questioned many baby food related companies about the use of DHA and the Organic label. Not one of the 6 offered a response! If you look closely at the Organic label requirements, you will see that the "Organic" designation is such that "no less than 95 percent of the.... More

  • reply

Add your comment

You can’t fool Mother Nature
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA

ADVERTISEMENT

About Jenn Savedge

Author of green parenting books blogs about raising eco-friendly kids.

Jenn's RSS Jenn's profile

From our sponsors

  • Recycling is No Longer Optional
  • Nutrition: Making a Good Dog Great
  • Quiz: Test Your Recycling Knowledge
  • 50 Money Saving Tips for Your Home
  • Taking Action on Climate Change
  • More Beer, Less Water
  • How We Made Our Car Run on Grease
  • Organic Grapes Make Better Wine
  • The Business Case for Sustainability

Mother Nature. Delivered.

MNN's weekly newsletter sent straight to your inbox.
Follow us on Twitter Fan us on Facebook

Jenn's BLOGROLL

Big Green PurseOrganic Mania
Crunchy ChickenGreen & Clean Mom
Not Quite Crunchy ParentThe Smart Mama
Fake Plastic FishGreen Phone Booth
Foodie TotsFoodie Tots

JENN'S RECENT POSTS

FINDING ECO-FRIENDLY FOOD OPTIONS
  • Spring projects for budding crafters
  • Parents respond to vaccine rulings
  • Scavenger hunt for spring
  • Read Jenn's Blog
+ add this to my site


Quick Links

  • Earth Matters
  • Lifestyle
  • Green Tech
  • Eco-Biz
  • Food
  • Your Home
  • Transportation
  • Family

 

  • Advice
  • Community
  • State Reports
  • Videos
  • Photos
  • Blogs

MNN Tools

  • About us
  • Advisory Board
  • Press
  • Sitemap
  • Privacy
  • Terms of service
  • Contact us

All About MNN

  • Join MNN
  • Newsletters
  • RSS
  • Eco-glossary
  • Widgets
  • MNN Contests
  • MNN Lists
  • MNN Mobile

 

Copyright © 2010 MNN Holdings, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Website by GLICK INTERACTIVE | Powered by COLOCUBE
 
SPONSORS