Are energy drinks safe?
Get the lowdown on energy drinks — what they are, when to use them and who shouldn't be drinking them at all.
Thu, May 17, 2012 at 12:15 PM
Since the 1997 introduction of Red Bull, energy drinks have seen exponential growth, outpacing nearly every other offering in the beverage market. From supermarkets to gas stations to drug stores, Red Bull, Five Hour Energy, Monster, Rockstar and other similar products dominate prime display space on shelves and in coolers. Responding to this placement and extensive advertising, consumers now spend more than $9 billion a year on energy drinks.
But do we really know what we're buying? Are these drinks safe? Do they carry health risks?
Before you reach for that magic bottle that promises enhanced alertness, concentration and physical performance, you need the facts.
Precise recipes vary, but the common element is caffeine.
A standard cup of coffee has about 100 milligrams of caffeine, a cup of tea 50 milligrams and a can of cola 35-55 milligrams. Energy drinks usually have more. A single serving of an energy drink can have anywhere from 50 to 500 milligrams of caffeine. And the addition of guarana (a South American plant extract that contains additional caffeine) ups the caffeine dose even more. Although the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) regulates the amount of caffeine in soft drinks (maximum of 71 milligrams per 12–ounce serving), there is no such limit for energy drinks.
Caffeine is a stimulant. Scientific studies in adults show that caffeine can increase alertness, improve concentration and enhance mood. Modest caffeine intake (less than 400 milligrams per day) is safe for most adults. But too much caffeine can cause problems, including restlessness, irritability and difficulty sleeping. Massive caffeine overdoses can cause reduced blood flow to the heart and abnormal heart rhythms.
Many energy drinks also contain sugar. Sugar is "real energy." Your body can use the sugar as fuel to do work. But don't forget that extra sugar means excess calories. A steady consumption of sugar-filled energy drinks will lead to weight gain.
Other ingredients, including the amino acid taurine, ginseng and assorted vitamins, probably have little to no impact on a person's perceived energy level. Although manufacturers tout the importance of these additives, their purported benefits are unproven. One note of caution: ginseng can interact with a variety of prescription medicines.
Energy drinks vs. sports drinks: Know the difference
Although often displayed in the same section of the store or even right next to each other, energy drinks (e.g. Monster, Five Hour Energy) and sports drinks (e.g. Gatorade, Powerade) are not interchangeable. Containing water, carbohydrates and electrolytes, sports drinks help athletes to rehydrate and replenish electrolytes and carbohydrates lost during strenuous athletic activity; this is a perfectly legitimate use of these products.
Energy drinks are different. Containing stimulants, they do not replenish electrolytes. Furthermore, caffeine can be dangerous for the dehydrated athlete who already has an elevated heart rate and blood pressure from physical exertion. Do not use energy drinks during sports; they do not provide the "energy" you need.
Energy drinks are not for kids
More than half of the energy drink market consists of children and young adults. Although endorsed by sports stars and targeted to younger people, energy drinks are not for kids. The American Academy of Pediatrics summed it up, concluding that "energy drinks have no place in the diet of children and adolescents."
Energy drinks and alcohol: Danger!
On Nov. 17, 2010, the FDA ruled that premixed drinks that include both alcohol and caffeine (alcoholic energy drinks) are unsafe. Although this stopped sales of such beverages, the ruling did not curtail the practice of combining alcohol with energy drinks. People just mix the drinks themselves. Surveys find that 25 to 50 percent of college students regularly consume combinations of energy drinks and alcohol. This is a dangerous practice.
The caffeine in energy drinks can counteract the drowsiness normally caused by alcohol. Drinkers stay awake longer and often drink more. This increases the risk of alcohol poisoning.
In addition, the energy drink can create the perception that the drinker is not impaired by the alcohol; the drinker feels more "alert" and believes that his reflexes (and driving ability) remain intact. This can lead to serious problems behind the wheel. Energy drinks do not counteract alcohol's effect on dulling reflexes.
If you are of age, drink alcohol responsibly. Don't mix alcohol and driving. And don't mix alcohol and energy drinks.
Are energy drinks for you?
In a court of law, we presume that a person is innocent until proven guilty. When it comes to medicine, we take the opposite approach. A drug or supplement is considered dangerous until proven safe.
Energy drinks have not been proven safe. In fact, because they are classified as supplements, they are not even regulated by the FDA. This means that their ingredients are not tightly controlled and their health effects are largely unstudied.
We do think that an adult who consumes an occasional energy drink (one a day) is unlikely to suffer harm. But too much can lead to caffeine overdose and health problems, and mixing energy drinks and alcohol is a bad idea. And remember — there is no justification for giving these drinks to children and teens.
Seek simpler and safer ways to maintain your energy and stay alert. Get a good night's sleep. Exercise daily. Eat well. These are the real magic bullets.
Also on YouBeauty.com:
- The downfall of drinking your calories
- Are you eating and drinking for your health and beauty?
- Healthy, tasty recipes to boost energy
- Related on MNN: Why does food safety testing matter? Consider this pizza
Steven Nissen, M.D & Marc Gillinov, M.D. originally wrote this story for YouBeauty.com. It is reprinted with persmission here.