I admit it: We’re Thin Mint addicts in our house. I try to limit the number of boxes I buy each season because they aren’t particularly healthy or earth-friendly. But, I have many friends with daughters in the Girl Scouts, and the Thin Mints are just so yummy.


My 7-year-old didn’t even realize there was any other flavor of Girl Scout cookies than Thin Mints. When one of my friends asked him what kind of cookies he wanted to buy from his daughter he said, “You know. Girl Scout cookies,” with a confused look on his face.


One reason that Girl Scout cookies hold such a spell over many people is that they are only available for a limited time. However, I’ve seen recipes for homemade versions of the cookies lately on different blogs.


Whether you’re looking to create a healthier version of the cookies that you like so much or you want a way to get your fix during the off-season, try your hand at these recipes for Girl Scout-like cookies.


  • Tagalongs Baking Bites has a recipe for these peanut butter patty Girl Scout cookies.
  • Thin MintsSerious Eats has a version of my family’s favorite that I’m going to have to try.
  • Samoas Christine’s Cuisine makes a duplicate of the chocolatey, caramely, coconutty cookies in bar form.
  • Do-Si-Dos - Baking Bites has a recipe for a larger version of these peanut butter sandwich cookies.
  • Shortbread Cookies CD Kitchen’s recipe makes 60 of these copy-cat cookies — more than you’d get in the seemingly ever shrinking box.
  • Thanks-a-lot Delish has a recipe for two-tone cookies that are like the chocolate and vanilla Girl Scout cookies.
  • The Original Cookies Lemondrop.com has a recipe for the original Girl Scout cookies. The ones the Scouts used to bake and sell for a quarter a dozen before they went with commercially baked.

The opinions expressed by MNN Bloggers and those providing comments are theirs alone, and do not reflect the opinions of MNN.com. While we have reviewed their content to make sure it complies with our Terms and Conditions, MNN is not responsible for the accuracy of any of their information.