SPECIAL FEATURES:
How important is a nickel?
When stores give you a few cents off for bringing your own bag, do you care?
Tue, Dec 07 2010 at 12:57 PM
Related Topics:
Photo: heypaul/Flickr
My husband handed me a receipt and a nickel as we were walking out of Target Saturday morning. I had handed him a ChicoBag to use while he made our purchases and I handled another task. For bringing his own bag, he was given a nickel. It made a big impression on him. He’s not one to remember to bring a bag with him when he goes shopping on his own, and he didn’t know that some stores give small rebates for each reusable bag you use.
The incident got me wondering. Does giving a few cents back per reusable bag encourage people to bring their own bags to the store? It’s certainly not a deciding factor for me. I’ve been bringing reusable bags to the store for years now, long before any store in my region instituted the incentive.
For those who aren’t completely committed to reusable bags, is the money an impressive enough gesture to get them to use reusable bags more often? My husband was impressed, and I believe the next time I suggest he grab a bag before heading to the store, he might do it.
It wasn't the money that impressed him; it was the gesture. It was recognition that he had done something a little praiseworthy. That nickel was like a gold star on top of a weekly third-grade spelling test. Remember those gold stars? When you got that gold star at the top of the page, you wanted to earn another gold star the following week.
So what do you think? Is the small rebate a useful symbol of a job well-done? Or am I over-thinking a nickel?
Also on MNN:
The opinions expressed by MNN Bloggers and those providing comments are theirs alone, and do not reflect the opinions of MNN.com. While we have reviewed their content to make sure it complies with our Terms and Conditions, MNN is not responsible for the accuracy of any of their information.
You might also like:
Sign in with one of these accounts to add your comment.

Email














I agree wholeheartedly, Julio. There is only one store in our area that offers paper bags. Unfortunately, it is one of the most expensive in which to shop. I generally buy my produce there because it offers the best, but for everyday staples, it is simply too expensive. You are absolutely right that all stores should be made to go back to paper and get rid of those plastic bags.
I don't think a nickel is much, but it adds up over time. What if stores charged you a nickel when you used their paper or plastic bags?
I don't think a nickel is much, but it adds up over time. What if stores charged you a nickel when you used their paper or plastic bags?
Canadian grocery stores have charged a nickel per bag for many years now, and it truly works. I never forget to bring my bags to the store with me! And many stores are willing to replace your canvas bags if they wear out for free.
That is what happens in the UK, and it sure does make a difference to people remembering to bring their own bags! Ok, not all stores charge for bags, but in those that do you don't see many people buying them.
I hear you. But how about enlisting their aid- ask them to remind you to bring the bags and the first one who does each time gets the nickle, the second one gets to help carry the bags, etc.
Teaches them about trying to help the environment, too!
Pat's idea is a good one! The way I keep from forgetting my bags in the car is by putting all the bags in one, and then putting my purse in that bag too. I never leave my purse in the car, so when I reach for my purse, I remember the bags. It's worked out very well for me.
Thanks! I like all your ideas! Now, I better write them down before I forget :) Since I'm a list person, perhaps I should add 'remember bags or box' to the top of the list each time. Lots of simple things to help me remember. And perhaps just adding a comment in this story will help me remember!
I shop at the local supermarket weekly. I fill up my shopping carts, almost always two carts a week. I take home around 25 bags a week. I use some for bathroom garbage, but the rest I take back to their recyle bin. Is this considered being green?
I have three kids and buy a lot at the grocery store too. The reusable bags actually fit more than the plastic ones and it makes it easier to carry them in the house too. You can put them up on your shoulders and now it takes fewer trips to get them all in the house.
Reusing and then recycling plastic bags are by far the most environmentally sound way to go. From the low enviro impact of the original manufacture to the highly cost effective & enviro sound ability to recycle, plastic bags out perform all other bag forms including cloth (most "cloth" bags are actually plastic..check the labels). Washing takes more energy & creates more pollution than using the same number of plastic bags to do the same job. Not popular, but very true.
If you don't want to buy reusable bags, maybe just bring the plastic bags back to the store and use them again instead of recycling them. They fold down super-small and are easy to keep in your purse.
Now I am curious what the heck are you folks who use plastic bags for trash, putting in the trash?
I line the small trash cans in each bathroom, kitty litter, anything super smelly from the kitchen, diapers etc. In the summer I use them as gloves to pull poison ivy - just turn the bag inside out around the pulled plant, tie off and throw away.
I rescue cats, at any given time I have up to 15 being fostered, that's a lot of litter. I use them to clean the boxes out. So if you have no need for those plastic bags, please send them my way! ;)
Is that kitty litter you use biodegradeable? Is there any other uses for that stuff? Maybe fertilizer? any ideas?
Now I am curious what the heck are you folks who use plastic bags for trash, putting in the trash?
I've always used my plastic bags as trash bags. What do those of you who have re-usable bags use for trash bags? Was told one would just have to BUY trash bags now. So in essence, nothing is really saved unless you're a waster of resources to begin with.
Pages