Can the cinnamon challenge kill you?
An Internet meme with potentially risky consequences is sweeping the Web. The question is, can the brutal 'cinnamon challenge' be potentially fatal as well?
Photo: katrindell/iStockphoto
|
Can the cinnamon challenge kill you?An Internet meme with potentially risky consequences is sweeping the Web. The question is, can the brutal 'cinnamon challenge' be potentially fatal as well?By Melissa BreyerFri, Feb 03 2012 at 1:22 PM EST
113
Photo: katrindell/iStockphoto
If someone can explain the appeal of the cinnamon challenge, can they clue in the rest of us? The dastardly dare that has the Internet aflutter involves the task of eating a teaspoon of ground cinnamon, without water, in less than a minute.
What could be so tough about consuming a mouthful of this innocuous-seeming spice? If cinnamon inspires thoughts of comforting apple pie and cozy cinnamon rolls, switch gears and consider Atomic Fireballs, Lava Hot Cinnamon Balls, and Hot Tamales. Cinnamon is potent, as evidenced by the reactions recorded in many a cinnamon-challenge YouTube video — coughing, choking, gagging, vomiting, crying, cursing and general signs of severe discomfort.
But all the panicked retching aside, can swallowing a mouthful of cinnamon be dangerous, or even deadly?
To understand the potency of cinnamon, ponder this: Cinnamaldehyde, the organic compound that gives the spice its distinctive flavor, is used as a pesticide and fungicide. It’s strong enough to kill little things, for heaven’s sake. The EPA warns of acute dermal toxicity; acute oral toxicity; eye irritation; dermal irritation and dermal sensitization. Granted, this is just a component of cinnamon used in concentration, but still, this demure seasoning clearly has a wicked side.
Related on MNN: A parent's guide to the cinnamon challenge
There are two species used in the ground cinnamon found in the spice aisle, Ceylon cinnamon and Cassia cinnamon. Cassia is interesting in that it contains substantial amounts of coumarin. Coumarin is the parent compound of warfarin (known by its trademarked name, Coumadin), a medication used to keep blood from clotting. Coumarin is mighty powerful and can affect blood sugar levels in people with diabetes. In people who are sensitive, coumarin might cause or worsen liver disease.
Due to concerns about the possible effects of coumarin, several years ago the German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment warned against consuming large amounts of Cassia cinnamon.
And then there’s the burn. Parenting experts recommend keeping spices out of reach from children. One of the threats to children who play in the spice cabinet is cinnamon, which when ingested can cause severe burning of the mouth and throat, requiring immediate medical attention. The burning may be so severe that the child can suffer from swelling of the mouth or throat, blocking access to air and potentially leading to death.
Obviously infants aren’t participating in the dare, and it's highly doubtful we'll witness an infant cinnamon challenge trend, but it goes to show that cinnamon is a formidable flavoring. All one needs to see is a few “cinnamon challenge fail” videos on the Web to view the effect on teens and young adults when the powder is inhaled — which is pretty much inevitable following the gasps that occur upon the initial burning. Immediate coughing and choking are de rigeuer.
Also on MNN: 13 plants that could kill you
In many cases, the coughing is so severe that the challengee has difficulty catching his breath. For anyone suffering from asthma or COPD, this can be very serious. And in fact, ground cinnamon can lead to a bronchial constriction — according to the University of Michigan Health System — and that can be life threatening.
Cinnamon also contains as essential oil called cinnamal, which can act as an allergen in a fair amount of people. Those who are allergic to cinnamon can suffer from contact dermatitis — and according to the University of Maryland Medical Center, cinnamon can also cause a severe allergic reaction that can lead to anaphylactic shock. We can only hope that someone who knows they are allergic to cinnamon would politely decline the challenge; but for someone who wasn’t aware of the existence or severity of an allergy, the results could be … challenging.
So, can the cinnamon challenge kill you? Although no accounts of death by cinnamon have been reported, there are indeed risks — and it seems only a matter of time until the challenge delivers a fatal blow to some unsuspecting teen.
You might also like:
Comments
Samantha
05/25/2012 18:18 PM
i havent tried the cinnamon challenge yet, but judjing on the the three videos that i have watch, it seems very dangerous. so people who do tke the cinnamon challenge are retarded.regardless on how cool or popular you want to be, taking the cinnamon challenge is not the way.and grown-ups should be warned about the cinnamon challenge and disscuss it with their kids, before[sorry for the bad news]he or she takes it and dies.
Courtney
05/16/2012 16:42 PM
#im sorry but this stuff is dangerous and i don't care what anybody says about it not being dangerous when you know it is..It has killed many people! some people need a life if there sitting here wasting there life on this stupid mess!!
valentina
05/15/2012 21:32 PM
i did the cinnamon challenge............. and i puked..... it was not fun at all......... Some people dont even take a ''spoonfull of cinnamon'' they take a really bid portion'' lol welll dont die people!
Enter your name
05/13/2012 02:19 AM
I found out my son took a spoonful of cinnamon in the afternoon and has now thrown up twice during the night. I'm worried about his airway-bronchial spasm.
steve uk
05/08/2012 16:55 PM
1/4 tea spoon of cinnamon in oatmeal and coffee every day helps lower your sugar levels if to high. Most people with type 2 have tried this and it works. helping lowering there levels. Plus why is it in the top 10 health foods. Yes i agree use it wise,
Disgusted
05/01/2012 14:41 PM
Just one more stupid kids think up to do. And for the life of me I can't figure out why. There are so many good things to do in the world and all that comes to their mind is garbage.
Luke
04/24/2012 21:56 PM
If they want to do the cinnamon challenge and endanger themselves, why should anyone else worry about it? social darwinism at its finest.
Enter your name
04/21/2012 02:16 AM
8 and 9 year olds doing the challenge....so scary!!!!!!!!
This is whats wrong with america
04/10/2012 12:29 PM
I don't think the overwhelming concern on this topic is necessary. The truth is, nobody has died from it, and besides a short trip to the hospital, it's harmless. Skateboarding causes 10x more injuries. What we should be talking about is the effect of propaganda like "Jersey Shore". Thats the REAL poison infecting our country today.
Karen Saucedo
04/09/2012 23:36 PM
I, in fact, have a thing for cinnamon and I do often eat a teaspoon of it. Good cinnamon has a bit of sweetness to it and for some reason, I found I operate well after taking a teaspoon WITH WATER. That said, this "challenge" is silly. If you want a challenge, replace the cinammon with cayenne pepper. I HAVE nearly killed myself accidentally inhaling cayenne from things I've sprinkled it on (I also love hot spices...ha ha).
Me
04/09/2012 18:51 PM
The problem with this challenge is the fact it is children/Teens that are doing it! More information needs to be targeted at their age group concerning the risks involved. Consenting adults are allowed to choose to take risks.Such acts as refusing surgery or medical drugs may put their life at risk, but if they are seen to be competant and able to understand the risks and retain this information they should be allowed to make their own decission under no pressure!
BH
03/30/2012 20:22 PM
This is indeed dangerous - just heard today about a Canadian teen who died suddenly in her sleep a few weeks ago. Her death is being attributed to the cinnamon challenge, which she and a friend were doing that evening. A co-worker told me this - the girl was a friend of her nieces. Very, very sad and so unnecessary.
Sensationalism.
Today 01:17 AM
This article is sensationalism. What else needs to be said?
pf
03/19/2012 18:26 PM
First of all the cinnammon challenge has been on the internet longer than 2012. People only send awareness now because of popularity? This thing became popular 2008, then came in another new energy. It is as if people forget a fad and then when it comes back they think its the first since since discovering a galaxy.
Hannah Grace
04/16/2012 00:44 AM
Yeah, I agree. I had heard about this challenge years ago. Also, it was originally from 2001, but really it did become popular just a few years ago.
leesomerset
03/16/2012 14:42 PM
I just read an article at InsidersHealth about this as well, dangerous health games kids play. They listed the cinnamon challenge as having a health risk, but there are so many other games that kids take a chance with (like the choking game or eyeball vodka shots) that make cinnamon seem innocent!
Chanel
03/11/2012 20:51 PM
I totally agree! This is dangerous, and has a risk of dying. This should be a felony or something. Like insulting a bus operator is a felony. Let's work together as a group and try to stop this, if parents work together, we could save the lives of innocent teenagers!
Anonymous
04/03/2012 19:59 PM
::sarcasm:: Ban the sale and possession of all cinnamon in the USA.
Anonymous
03/19/2012 16:51 PM
Why should taking the cinnamon chalange be a felony? there is konw reason for making it a felony. that would be the peoples fault for takin the chalange. if they get sick and die from it that would eventually be their fault.
bibi
03/14/2012 08:48 AM
the cinamon challenge is sooo not dangerous! if you think it is then you must not have a strong stomach, and you must not be very brave or courageous. i did the cinamon challenge in my friends back garden with my other friend,, she started choking and spluttering , but it had no effect on me, and i did it in about 30 seconds. without water. and i had a lot on my spoon,it was as much as a shot of alcohol and a half. it tasted disgusting, but i completed it without showing any sifns of.... More
Anonymous
04/19/2012 22:44 PM
Yes because EVERYBODY reacts the same way to things -sarcasm- Not even just because of allergies, but did you ever accidentally swallow something "down the wrong tube"? Doing that here could be fatal.
Anonymous
03/15/2012 16:14 PM
Yes well the whole point of the article is that different people have different pre-existing conditions which can make them more susceptible to being harmed by this. Just because it didn't have any effect on you, does not mean it can't harm someone else.
Haha
03/09/2012 14:09 PM
Please I'll take a cup of it and eat it
phil
03/08/2012 09:04 AM
i don't get why people even take the challenge, i mean why would they do it, to be cool? you put your life at risk
kris
03/15/2012 00:13 AM
It's cause it tastes so good
Shiloh2000
03/06/2012 19:25 PM
I think we better make cinnamon illegal immeidately to keep it out of the hands of teenagers. It's clearly a gateway drug.
Anonymous
03/12/2012 12:10 PM
i think your bad at thinking cinnamon is really good there is nothing wrong with it. It do not need to be taken away from us. DISLIKE
Timmy
03/04/2012 10:10 AM
I had a buddy do a similar challenge and thankfully, all turned out ok in the end, but it was a little dicey for a while, I'm not going to lie. The scene was Austin, Texas, in the late 90's. We were visiting an old college buddy to hit the bars on 6th street, and chase some chicks quite frankly. However, prior to going out on a big Saturday night, we had some idle time during the day where some macho bets began to take place. In the end, we settled on one where our Austin host agreed to.... More
Justme
03/02/2012 04:25 AM
Tablespoon, not teaspoon. Correct????
Anonymous
03/02/2012 19:28 PM
YES! afaik that is . . . a teaspoon isn't that much, and a tablespoon is 3 teaspoons
GeoCar
02/28/2012 10:29 AM
Cinnamon contains coumarin, an anti-coagulant and possibly carcinogenic substance that can cause liver inflammation. One source said that as little as three cinnamon cookies could contain enough of the toxin to harm a small child. There are two kinds of cinnamon, but product labels do not usually identify the type. Ceylon or true cinnamon is a pale tan color; it is milder, sweeter, and more expensive than cassia. Cassia, or common cinnamon, is redder, stronger in flavor, and cheaper..... More
Joebobjim
02/27/2012 16:51 PM
Every little potential hazard with trying to eat a tsp of cinnamon could be applied to anything else that's a dare or a challenge! A tsp of cayenne, for example. A tsp of Dave's Insanity Sauce. A tsp of black pepper, or nutmeg, or mustard powder, or dirt, or even unpasteurized milk for gosh sake. Proving that the weak should just stay inside and do nothing their whole lives to stay perfectly safe.
Anonymous
03/11/2012 01:26 AM
Unpasturized milk is actually healthier and contains nutrients that are killed or altered in the pasturization process.
Dante Alset
03/08/2012 21:59 PM
I'm pretty sure stuff like cayenne, dirt, and black pepper are not toxic. Also, people usually drink more than a tsp of unpasteurized milk (tsp = tablespoon = large spoonful). On a side note, nutmeg is actually poisonous and has killed people before and been used to induce abortions.
Catherine
02/27/2012 12:09 PM
I think most of you are missing the point. Kids are doing are ingesting cinnamon without water, videotaping it and posting it on facebook. I am a nurse and had a 15 year old hospitalized for 5 days because as she was ingesting it she inhaled some of the cinnamon and it inflamed her airway then she ended up with pneumonia.
Steven Forester
02/25/2012 23:12 PM
This is so silly. I was raised eating cinnamon sprinkled on butter toast from the time I could eat for myself. I'm sure a tablespoon would taste pretty horrible, but it certainly isn't toxic to children or something in reasonable amounts.
Claudia Smith
04/25/2012 18:06 PM
Oh I too have had cinnamon combined with sugar on my french toast, but it is more sugar then cinnamon and it isn't a whole spoonful by it self. My daughter did the cinnamon challange and she said it came out her nose, she couldn't breathe and felt like throwing up. It scared the crap out of her. I'm happy she is alive. Most parents don't know their kids did the challange, I just happened to over hear mine did it this past year. (I was clueless about what it was, I wish someone have .... More
Gaalee
02/25/2012 23:12 PM
Judging from the comments there's plenty of people who didn't really interpret what the article says.
lady red chelli
02/20/2012 11:14 AM
cinnamon cakes and cookies is tasty,,,but we still living
James Larkin
02/20/2012 02:59 AM
I don't know what stupid challenge you are on about but my wife and I take cinnamon daily to reduce blood sugar levels and it does work. I never heard of it being dangerous although of course anything in excess can create problems.
Claudia Smith
04/25/2012 17:56 PM
James we are talking about pure cinnamon on a spoon , not in pill form. My husband takes cinnamon also (pill form) for diabetes as well.
Tarrant
02/21/2012 08:44 AM
This is a trendy dare for young people.They take spoons full of dry cinnamon and swallow without water or food. It isn't the same as sprinkling cinnamon on food or mixing with beverages, or taking in a capsule form.
Enter your name
02/19/2012 13:45 PM
I've done it....and i'm still living...
Adi
02/18/2012 15:07 PM
I just took the challenge, twice today.....I'm still alive :I Add your commentSign in with one of these accounts or just add your comment below. |
ADVERTISEMENTADVERTISEMENT |
Copyright © 2012 MNN Holdings, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Website by GLICK INTERACTIVE | Powered by CIRRACORE |
| SPONSORS |