Magical misery tours
These depressing "vacation" spots won't be offering a breath of fresh air.
Tue, Mar 24, 2009 at 11:27 AM
Eco-tourism typically conjures up images of pristine forests and beaches. Now, some environmental groups are offering another type of trip—tours of places ravaged by pollution. Whether you’re after a glimpse of Texas’ Refinery Row or a journey through Louisiana’s Cancer Alley, there are sites to shock even the most intrepid traveler. We’ve collected “brochures” from a few toxic tourism destinations.
Run by: Catholic Committee of Appalachia
Sights to see: Father John Rausch leads a tour of vast coal mines created by blasting the tops off mountains.
Typical crowd: Religious eco-warriors
Kodak moment: Sing hymns just 200 feet from an exploding mountain. “It’s like an earthquake,” says Rausch. “It’s visceral!”
Take-home message: Some mines are the size of Manhattan, and their waste has clogged 1,200 miles of mountain streams.
Los Angeles, California
Run by: Communities for a Better Environment
Sights to see: Visit neighborhoods overshadowed by massive port terminals and refineries.
Typical Crowd: College students and high school kids
Kodak moment: Watch flares rise from the refineries. “It’s kind of like candlelight,” says program director Yuki Kidokoro—although, the rotten-egg stench can spoil the effect.
Take-home message: Overdevelopment stinks, especially if you live next door.
Run by: Digital artist Brooke Singer
Sights to see: Log on for virtual tours of the country’s most contaminated spots—one for each day of the year. Or, take a self-guided tour to a local landmark identified on the site and post your own material.
Typical crowd: Green geeks
Kodak moment: View interactive flower charts of each site’s pollutants—one petal per contaminant.
Take-home message: Some sites are so filthy that you’ll be glad you stayed home.
Fort McMurray, Alberta
Run by: Fort McMurray Tourism and Suncor Energy
Sights to see: Behold the massive machinery used to extract oil from oil sands—but don’t expect to hear much about the industry’s environmental toll.
Typical crowd: Plant workers’ parents
Kodak moment: Pose for photos in a bucket the size of a two-car garage. “We’ve put whole bus tours in there,” says tourism director Helen Daymond.
Take home message: Oil extraction can be fun! And our tractors are bigger than yours.
Matamoros, Mexico; Brownsville, Texas
Run by: Local activist Domingo Gonzalez
Sights to see: Cross the Rio Grande to see poorly regulated Mexican factories making goods for US consumers.
Typical crowd: Hardcore environmentalists
Kodak moment: Watch children scavenge in burning garbage dumps just yards from the US border.
Take-home message: NAFTA isn’t good news for everyone.
Story by Ben Whitford. Illustration by Josh Cochran. This article originally appeared in "Plenty" in August 2008.