How do you remove your eye makeup at night? While some environmentalists swear by olive oil -- or even the soap-and-water-only method -- many eco-beauty mavens want a less crunchy solution. So I put two greener eye makeup removers -- both of which got a "low hazard" score of 2 on the Skin Deep cosmetic safety database -- to the test.

First up: Aubrey Organics Herbessence Makeup Remover. While Aubrey's a very health and environmentally counscious company, I unfortunately find that many of Aubrey's products don't work for me. This makeup remover was no exception, because it felt exactly like rubbing pure oil on my eyelids — which made me think I may as well use olive oil and save myself some money.

My second choice -- Earth Science Eye Make-Up Remover -- fared a lot better. This fragrance-free, paraben-free product is a clear gel that’s non-greasy and does its job quite well.

I’m fairly happy with Earth Science, but it seems there are quite a few eye makeup removers on the market that score a 0 ranking on Skin Deep, making them even safer than my current product! I’m now curious about trying those, though I’d rather not run into another bad Aubrey-like experience.

Got an eco eye makeup remover to recommend? Share your reviews in the comments!

Thumbnail photo: Lindsay Loo Brush. Post photos: Courtesy and

The opinions expressed by MNN Bloggers and those providing comments are theirs alone, and do not reflect the opinions of While we have reviewed their content to make sure it complies with our Terms and Conditions, MNN is not responsible for the accuracy of any of their information.