Here comes a new shoe option that helps make eco-footwear fashionable and popular — but also leaves me a tad puzzled: Keds, Loomstate and Barneys New York are teaming up to create and sell Keds made with organic cotton uppers and a recycled insole board.

Organic Keds designed by Loomstate

No, my befuddlement doesn’t come from the juxtaposition of high and low fashion; Barneys and Loomstate have both teamed up with Target before. For this project, Loomstate is designing the shoes, Keds is making the, and Barneys is selling them for a win-win-win.

I’m bewildered, instead, because Keds actually launched a green line back in March, also made with organic cotton. The cost of those (below): $55 a pair. The cost of this Keds-Loomstate-Barneys shoes (above): $75 a pair.

Keds Green Line

There may be a percentage difference in the recycled content in the insoles and outsoles, but from what I can tell, the shoes are pretty much the same except for the colors in the uppers: The $55 pairs come in just three solid hues, while the $75 pairs come in five multicolored designs — which granted, do seem somewhat prettier.

On a philanthropical level, the $75 shoes will send 1 percent of sales to The Organic Exchange, while the $55 shoes will plant a tree through the Arbor Day Foundation.

Other than that, the difference in the shoes simply has to do with the brand-cache of Loomstate and Barneys. Like the multicolored designs enough to pay $20 extra a pair? Pick them up at Barneys New York stores later this week.

Photos courtesy of Keds

The opinions expressed by MNN Bloggers and those providing comments are theirs alone, and do not reflect the opinions of While we have reviewed their content to make sure it complies with our Terms and Conditions, MNN is not responsible for the accuracy of any of their information.