Make the switch to a natural deodorant

Aluminum is found in most conventional deodorants and has been linked to breast cancer. If you want to eliminate it from your toiletries, try these options.
By Chris BaskindTue, Apr 13 2010 at 2:36 PM EST  106 Comments

Photo: iStockphoto
So let's talk armpits. Specifically, let's talk about something you probably put on your armpits every morning: deodorants and antiperspirants. These B.O. blasters come in almost every scent imaginable, in forms from roll-ons to clear gels. Your supermarket aisle probably stocks two dozen varieties.
 
 
  
Earn Points
What's this?
Almost every one will have something in common: aluminum chlorohdrate or aluminum zirconium. And that could be a problem.
 
Concern about aluminum
Natural health groups have been pressing government and regulatory agencies for years to take a hard look at the long-term safety of aluminum in cosmetic products. Aluminum is what gives antiperspirants their wetness-fighting ability, and they're highly effective. Commercial deodorants can contain up to 25 percent aluminum salts by weight.
 
The problem is this: nobody really knows what aluminum does in the human body. In the case of deodorants, you’re applying aluminum directly to the skin and leaving it there. With women, in particular, that skin might be broken from shaving.
 
You'll notice most antiperspirants contain a warning to discontinue use if you experience irritation from its use, and quite a few people are sensitive to the aluminum salts, parabens and triclosan common in over-the-counter products. But what really worries some health experts is aluminum's possible connection to breast cancer.
 
The cancer question
Before we go any further, let's be clear: despite the flackery you'll find on the internet, there are no definitive studies which link the use of antiperspirants to an increased risk of cancer. These concerns have been floating around for at least a decade, and groups such as the American Cancer Society still consider commercial deodorants to be safe.
 
That hasn't stopped some researchers from fretting. Take Dr. Philippa Darby of the U.K.'s University of Reading. She's recently published a paper in the Journal of Applied Toxicology showing that aluminum salts increase estrogen-related gene expression in cultured human breast cancer cells. In other words, the aluminum appears to mimic estrogen under lab conditions. Elevated estrogen levels are tied to a higher risk of breast cancer.
 
More study is in order, but Darby's research raises new question for investigators.
 
Safer deodorants
Maybe you're concerned about the possible risk factors of commercial deodorants, or you're someone with skin sensitivities. Perhaps you're just looking to reduce the chemical exposure in your life. The good news is there are effective deodorants which don't use aluminum chlorohydrate or aluminium zirconium — and they're cheap!
 
We all want to smell good and feel clean. Those not-so-fresh moments are caused by bacteria which thrive in warm, moist places. Armpits are the Monte Carlo of the single-cell jet set. But you can deport them with an inexpensive deodorant stone.
 
These stones — sometimes called by one of their trade names, Thai Sticks — are large, smooth crystals of potassium alum (potassium aluminum sulfate). Potassium alum is a naturally occurring form of aluminum salt. The difference between potassium alum and aluminum chlorohydrate is that potassium alum is a much larger molecule, not thought to be absorbable through human skin. Wet the stone and apply it like a conventional roll on. Rinse and set it aside to dry. That's it.
 
There are no perfumes or additives, and you probably won't need any. A deodorant stone doesn't stain, and it works all day. If you want something fancier, there are spray and roll-on versions with additives such as aloe and essential oils. Jason, Alba, Thai Stick and Kiss My Face are among those you'll find online or at your local natural health store.
 
A plain stone will cost you $5 or $6, and could last up to a year.
 
If you're looking to completely eliminate aluminum from your deodorant and your medicine cabinet, there are other options. Tom's of Maine makes a well-regarded line of non-aluminum products featuring zinc ricinoleate and natural ingredients. Zinc ricinoleate is also the basis of Dr. Hauschka Deodorant Fresh in scented and floral formulas. Burt's Bees Herbal Deodorant uses oil of sage for its active ingredient, and Trader Joe's sells a natural deodorant which relies on a cotton product to approximate the antiperspirant action of aluminum zirconium. Surprisingly, mainline manufacturer Adidas also makes a non-aluminum deodorant: Adidas 24-Hr Control. It's not expensive, and the sort of thing you'd find in a conventional drugstore.
 
Copyright Lighter Footstep 2007
 
CLOSE link:

Comments

View:

Another great commercial deoderant



Unsure why no one has mentioned these great natural products here yet - LUSH makes some great deodorants. I've been using it for years, and the comment I get most is "what's that perfume you have on?" (if the day has gotten a bit warm).
Yes, LUSH is a commercial product; No, I am not paid by them.

Finally found something that works!!!



I have been trying for years to ween myself off of regular deoderant. The point is we don't want to use the aluminum products they can cause health issues. Remembering that you are putting something toxic under your arms going directly to the area of your breast. Not good. I went into a organic market and found a product called odor cleanse that works to neutralize odor from the inside. It worked!!! See we want to sweat, it's a natural body function. What we don't want is the odor, which comes.... More

natural stuff doesn't work on some people



Same with the no 'poo crowd.... if you're one of the lucky folks who don't produce oil like the Deep Horizon, yay. Forgo your deo and your 'poo. For us folks who sweat buckets and work with our bodies for a living, b.s. like the 'stone, etc. just doesn't work. The only thing I have not yet tried is the baking soda (prolly cuz it was too simple to be believable, I dunno). I'm gonna try it--I'm assuming it is to be "dusted" with a scooch or two into the palm and then dusted up into the 'pit--why.... More

Mixed martial artists use my deodorant, and they sweat more than



Hi JustJack, I just read your post. My name is Jeremiah Blattler, I am the owner of Jungleman All-Natural Deodorant. I formulated my deodorant because the other all-natural ones sucked big time, as you just mentioned. I just posted under yours with a huge rant about how toxic those crystals are (in addition to being ineffective).

I guarantee you that my deodorant is different from those poison crystals, or Tom's of Maine, Terra Naturals, or Burt's Bee's Wax, as mine is.... More

Deodorant crystals ARE NOT safe!



Hi, my name is Jeremiah Blattler. I am the owner and creator of Jungleman All-Natural Deodorant, the only TRULY all-natural deodorant that actually works, unlike Tom’s of Stain (owned by Colgate Palmolive), Burt’s Allergic Crapwax (owned by Clorox), and is devoid of toxins like aluminum (all types of aluminum, not just aluminum chloride), unlike these poison crystals being pawned all over the internet.

My product DOES NOT contain: aluminum, parabens, peroxides, alcohols,.... More

Luv Dis Article



Great information...Love reading the comments to

Make Informed Decisions, Not Knee-Jerk Reactions



I'm astounded that the writer states "nobody really knows what aluminum does in the human body" but you shouldn't use it anyway. Then, the writer states "The difference between potassium alum and aluminum chlorohydrate is that potassium alum is a much larger molecule, not thought to be absorbable through human skin." NOT THOUGHT to be absorbable. THEY DON"T KNOW!!! Why would anyone trust that and make decisions and life changes based on wild guesses?

While the American Cancer Society sees.... More

Not Mentioned



I use a "long lasting" deodorant called Lavilin. It has tea tree oil in it. A small container of it costs about $12 but lasts a year or more. I don't even put it on every day. In the winter it will go a week and in the summer a couple of days.

Store Bought "Natural" Deodorants don't work? Make your own.



For those of you saying that the thai sticks aren't working as well as other more natural deoderants, you may try making your own. I've been doing it for a few weeks now and it works great for me. Ingrediants are simple and it takes about 5 minutes to make enough to last you at least a few months. You can google all kinds of recipes, but I use 1/4 cup of baking soda, 1/4 cup of cornstarch, and 1 1/2 to 2 tbsp of coconut oil along with about 10 drops of essential oil (for a nice smell, but you.... More

?



if you leave it in the container, then how or what do you use to apply it?

homemade deodorant



I just made the deodorant. is it supposed to be a paste or do I need to add more coconut oil? I added honeysuckle drops and it smells good...didn't have any vitamin e, so went without it. also wondering if it stains any fabric???

Won't Rubbing Alcohol and Tea Tree Oil Burn After You Shave?



So, I always seen to sweat more after I shave (I have no idea why), but wouldn't alcohol or tea tree oil sting and cause red irritation? Same with lemon or lime juice.
I have tried Tom's antiperspirants, but they didn't work at all.
The stones gave me a rash, and I can't get the Tai sticks anywhere because they are weed...

So any answers or suggestions?
Thanks!

Cure for deodorant



Try using baking soda alone. Just a pinch after you shower should keep you odor free (at least greatly reduced) for 24 hours.

Most don't work - the crystal does



I live in a tropical country and I sweat a LOT. I've tried may deodorants over the years and have for the past several years settled on the deodorant crystal. I've tried every one mentioned in this article - it's the only one that has worked for me. I just make sure to apply it more than once in the morning and I'm fine for the rest of the day. I prefer the spray to the actual crystal tho.

Web of Life Connects All Things as One



I discovered and have confirmed through personal trial that unscented old fashioned plain milk of magnesia applied wet after a shower and allowed to dry provides a minimum of 24 hours of odor protection if sweating is minimal. That is on a man that otherwise develops a rather ripe level of B.O.

Web of Life Connects All Things as One



I like the idea of the lemon. I have to try that next. No one here mentioned that aluminum causes Alzheimer's. I don't care which one you buy with it they are all bad that have it. The best options I have found commercially are Alba Botanicals Organic; Propylene Glycol Aluminum and Paraben Free, and Perhaps an essential oil infused alcohol spray like burts bees. I think one could also use a combinations of antimicrobial essential oils in combination with some light oil; i.e. lavender, tea.... More

Some natural stuff just doesn't work



I'm a daily showerer and a big supporter of Tom's of Maine products in general, but their deodorant *does not work.* It might smell nice initially, and it doesn't irritate, but when I was using it regularly, I'd need to apply it every couple of hours -- and even then, I still stank by the end of the day and every time a broke a sweat. I switched back to commercial deodorants, and the problem was gone.

Also, my wife (who showers twice daily) tried using The Body Shop's DeoDry aluminum-free.... More

Natural Deodorant



My husband and I use tea tree oil instead of deodorant. I am sensitive to aluminum and copper(will break out in a rash), so this article explains why I have been unable to wear deodorant. Tea tree oil works by stopping the bacteria that cause odors. It also smells quite nice, but not too girly or masculine.. just earthy. As with everything new, please test a bit on your skin before applying to rule out sensitivity. You can buy it at a health store for 5 or six bucks and it only takes one.... More

great



I really like the information I'm getting from reading the article and all these comments. I'm beginning to take a closer look at the things I use on a daily basis.

Love the salt sticks



I have been using salt sticks for 6 months now and I am a happy customer. No bad odor. I also carry it with me to use if I want to freshen up. One thing you must know is that these salt sticks are not antiperspirants so you will sweat. Thats why if you are very active, at time you will need to get to a bathroom wash up and reapply the deodorant. I do this because I work with children and I move around a lot but when I am not at work, I don't need to do anything.

What you eat can make a difference



Garlic and onions can greatly add to one's B.O. Eliminate both of these from your diet and you will definately notice a difference

another scam about naural products



alimunum being linked to breast cancer in deodorants has LONG since and clearly been cleared up as incorrect data. this is just more hype on the 'natural' market to sell us crap.

another scam about natural products



Notice : there are scammers every where especially if they can make a buck from it. Don't be a chump check it out for your self then you will know the truth, I certinly would not trust corporate advice, they are the same type of folk who killed all the buffalo and left them in the field to wrot. The other side are the same type who would sell you snake oil, piss on your leg and tell you you need to buy their rain proof pants. Which one will you believe???

good stone??



It's an Obama administration plot. Use golf oil it's cheeper

Oh big SHOCKER



a republican misspelling Golf instead of GULF? SHOCKER.... not... probably fornicates his "kin" as well, lmao

takes one to know one



You must be lost. Why don't you join your mindless camrades on some other site and post your ignorant, insulting comments there?

Really?



So, yer a better persin cuz u can spel better?
Nice show of arrogance.

ahem



It's not arrogance, it's intelligence...
I definitely take pride in not sounding and looking like an idiot.

Typical



I guess we'll never really know what you look or sound like. Maybe we could borrow your all-knowing extreme intelligence and come up with some pretty good ideas. If you can know for fact that someone who misspells a word is a republican - you must be god or a lib.

ahem



in your case it is arrogance..... someone who is truely intelligent doesn't belittle others,not everyone is fortunate enough to be able to get a decent education

well.....



well.... you "sound very rude" and you "look" like a total jerk..... all they did was spell it wrong. For pete's sake this isn't a spelling bee so calm down. And are you gonna go all over the internet and correct people? Also we can't see you any way so don't say "look" or "sound" beause all that does is give away that you think your smart but you may be not... IDK i'm not to judge anyway.....

MAKE THE SWITCH TO ANTURAL DEODERANT



taz, your humor, from here, smells like your breath and arm pits

...



You'd be more convincing if you could spell.

Even cheaper alum



sure, it's a great deal to buy a $5 rock and have a year's worth of deodorant. i used to be even more stingy and simply looked for it in bags (labeled "alum") at asian stores. for a $1 bag, you get even more alum (though in pieces, and not polished smooth, but it smooths out as you use it). i think it works by preventing the bacteria growth that makes you stink. so you have to always use it right after showering, and it wears off eventually; then if you don't shower bacteria starts to.... More

Natural products DO work



I'm a firm believer that several of the above options are very effective. I have used crystal stone, alcohol, peroxide and even a squirt of hand sanitizer in a pinch! I quit using antiperspirant after discovering that it didn't stop the odor for me, just the wetness. (And yes, I do shower VERY regularly!). Currently I'm using Degree deodorant (not antiperspirant) with honeysuckle and tea tree. Works very well, and is great to use on underarms and in the groin pit area too (another source of.... More

deodorant



I've been told to wash under your arms with soap and water, wipe dry and apply juice of a lime.

deodorant



If you do that, avoid sunlight exposure. I had lime juice on my hands once and went out in the sun. The sun turned my hands blistered and dark brown and they looked terrible for about 3 weeks. After thinking I had sun poisoning, I read up on it and found out about lime juice not mixing well with the sun. Just FYI...wouldn't want you to ruin a good vacation!

ye'r all nuts fer' nuttin'



just take a short shower twice a day and don't eat the crap that the fda pyramid says is good for you... crap in worse crap out...

help me!



i tried looking for the stones but cant find them if any one know's where i can get one please tell me!!! thanks in advance if anyone does help me....

Hmmm



You should be able to find them at Henry's, Sprouts, Trader Joe's, heck, I HATE WalMart and I've seen them there and at target, too.

Honestly, you'd be better off using essential oils, though. Tea Tree, Rosemary, etc.

deodorant stick



You can get them at your neighborhood Walgreens or CVS.
Not very expensive. My husband has used them for years and loves them. They really do last for quite of few months.

Less Harmful than Taxes.



Waking up in the morning can kill you. (Seriously, it
can. Your body undergoes a series of changes that
can actually cause death.)
And let's not talk of not waking up....
OK, let's get serious.
Not eating will kill you, and what you eat will change
how long the statisticians think you will probably live.
Usually, this change of probable lifespan is not a thing
that is of any concern.
- -
OK, now let's get really serious.
Tetanus.... More

help me!



Here you go. I didn't check pricing yet but here are some sites for the natural stones and crystals.
Or, search google for "natural deodorant stones" and you'll get a bunch of entries.

http://www.deodorantstones.com/
http://www.pureandnaturaldeodorant.com/
http://www.tawascrystal.com/
http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_ss_gw?url=search-alias%3Daps&field-keywor...

These are just a few.

Good

baking soda



After decades of intermittent body odor 'flare-ups' ---stress often a factor---heard about plain old baking soda. It works. At first used baking soda with my deodorant but find the deodorant completely unnecessary. Passed along hint to son who has similar problem ( inherited ? And yes, we shower ) and baking soda also works for him. Plus effect lasts for days when camping etc. Good stuff. Cheap. Easily accessible. Keep a box in the bathroom.

Don't Poo Poo Alcohol



The responders that say Tea Tree Oil prevents body odor may be right about that, but then smelling like tea tree oil sucks and is truly {excuse the pun), "the pits.
The responders that say lemon juice does the trick, may be right (I have never used it), but keeping a lemon fresh and and convenient is costly and difficult.
My friend, an older lady told me about alcohol a couple of years before I tried it. (I ran out of my expensive deodorant) I have never used anything but.... More

THAI STICKS



MAN THAI STICKS IS WEED AKA MARIJUANA YOU WANNA GET PULLED OVER BY THE COPS

THAI STICKS



I bet it smells good tho,

Thai *DEODORANT* Sticks



Umm, you people who keep replying, "Thai Sticks are MARIJUANA," please think before you reply. Would they actually suggest for you to rub marijuana on your armpits? They meant Thai DEODORANT sticks. They have stones, too, as mentioned in the article. Here is the THAI DEODORANT STICK website.

.... More

I switched to the Stone



I switched from conventional brands to the mineral stone about six months ago, and shower every day or every other day depending on what I'm doing. I have had no problems with the stone and if used properly I have noticed it protects against the 'smell' for up to 48 hours. In addition, I tried the spray version first and the roll on mineral versions which did not work for me nearly as well as the regular old stone itself. You don't need deoderants just kill the bacteria.

????????????



Just take a shower people. You all are retarded!

To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.
You can’t fool Mother Nature
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Notify me with an email when other people comment on this article.
Used only for emailed comments and will not be displayed with your post
WorldShares lets you earn donations for your favorite nonprofit. Earn up to 20 points now.
Learn More
Earn points, claim WorldShares, save the planet and win prizes!

ADVERTISEMENT

MNN ORIGINALS

Not sure which green way is best? Get answers from our experts.

We've got a new contest coming soon.

Government data you need to know, in a way you can understand.

Check out eco-photos of the week, top 10 lists and more.

Learn more about everything from acid rain to wildlife.