Expedition to the Raja Ampat Islands: Eco-resort protects coral reefs
A Napoleon wrasse in Southeast Misool. (Photo: Purwanto Irawan) 
link:
Comments(3)
Posted By Rick MacPherson - Sat, Jan 02 2010 at 1:14 AM ESTMPAs Work
A little knowledge, it's been said, can be a dangerous thing. But Kid Ingme's comment demonstrates that a complete absence of knowledge is even worse.
Do your homework on MPAs before you start your armchair critique. Shark's presence in effectively managed MPAs is a result of the upward trophic cascade that can result from protecting reef fish from poaching. Reef fish feed bigger fish. And sharks (who also happen to receive protection from poaching in managed MPA's like South Misool).... More
Posted By Kid Ingme - Fri, Jan 01 2010 at 12:56 PM ESTExpedition to the Raja Ampat Islands: Ecoresort protects coral r
This story is like so many skewed views of MPAs vs. Well thought out fishing regulations.
The picture perfect misdirection was flawless, until the mention of sharks and MPA's having a relationship.
Just a little tid bit of info, sharks as smart as they are, cannot read maps made by people. And since most sharks, including reef sharks, are Pelagic (look that one up, its a goody) there is NO proof that a large MPA would have any effect on shark populations.
In this story the real.... More



Facebook
Stumble
Tweet
Digg
Link














Expedition to the Raja Ampat Islands: Ecorecort protes coral ree
Kid Inigme, your comment, "The real reason you saw sharks in the MPA is because the resort most likely provides feeding tours for touristy types," is as ignorant as the statement in the story making a direct positive association between the sighting of sharks and the establishment of MPAs...the foundation for either statement is not provided to the reader. As a scientist (I am both a forensic and marine biologist) I rely upon collections of data and observations to support associations and.... More