SPECIAL FEATURES:
Spanish study still making headlines
A study that suggests each new green job will cost 2.2 regular jobs is still making news.
Wed, Apr 15 2009 at 7:56 PM
Several weeks ago, I posted about a Spanish study that suggests green jobs will come at the cost of non-green jobs. The Bloomberg article that I cited in my Green jobs at what cost? post was from March 27. Fast forward to this week and I’m suddenly seeing a surge in news alerts about this Spanish study.
It seems that some (people, organizations, news networks) have decided to take this study and use it to discredit President Obama’s call for a green jobs movement. The latest news alert that came across my email is from Media Matters for America. The authors of the article, Fox News pushing questionable Spanish study on green jobs, are upset with Fox News reporter Shannon Bream’s piece on the study.
“Fox News' Shannon Bream touted a Spanish study on green jobs to cast doubt on President Obama's proposal to fund green energy, without noting criticism of the study or that the study's author is reportedly a founding member of a group "aimed at countering panic connected with global warming." Source: Media Matters for America
The authors of the article on the Media Matters blog go on to discuss more of the uproar that this study has caused here in the U.S. media market.
Photo by microboy
The opinions expressed by MNN Bloggers and those providing comments are theirs alone, and do not reflect the opinions of MNN.com. While we have reviewed their content to make sure it complies with our Terms and Conditions, MNN is not responsible for the accuracy of any of their information.
You might also like:
Sign in with one of these accounts to add your comment.

Tracey de Morsella
May 24 2009 at 3:16 AM
The lead author, Gabriel Calzada Alvarez does not use a scientific approach to his "study." There are numerous flaws in his study and I do not think he is credible. to start, Caldaza uses falsified numbers in his study. The official estimate of green jobs created is 188,000, yet he says only 50,000 were created, and does not expain where that number comes from.
Spain's rates of unemplyment since it went democratic has consistently been extremely high. At the time of the study was conducted, Spain's
.... More
unemployment rate was high, but low when compared to previous years. Spain has had extremely high unemployment rates since it went democratic over 30 years ago. However, Spain's unemployment rates have been historically low during all of the years they have invested in renewable energy. Most credible economists believe Spains bursting real estate bubble is the primary cause of Spain's high unemployment rate. Calzada never even factors in the bubble.
Caldaza is an admitted climate change denier and speaks regularly to climate change denial groups. He is backed by ExonMobil, who has spent over $16 million to fund climate change skeptic groups as part of a "tobacco-like disinformation campaign on global warming science." The purpose of the study was not to point out flaws in Spain's economic policy, but to raise doubt and shut down support for similar policies in the US.
There are other flaws with the study, too numerous to list here, but I wrote a post with statistics and a response from an offical from Spain on my blog at: http://greeneconomypost.com/debunk-spanish-study-green-jobs-1582.htm
- Log in or register to post comments
- Report This Post

Email














Join the conversation