MNN.COM > MNN BLOGGERS > Jim Motavalli's Blog

Jim Motavalli

Sudden acceleration: Electronic interference could be a cause

Today's cars use 'throttle by wire' technology, and it's possible that the electronic signals could be jammed by other devices in your vehicle's complex computerized environment.
Tue, Feb 02 2010 at 3:15 PM EST
Read more: ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH, SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY

COLLISION COURSE: Toyota's Matrix, recalled for unintended acceleration. (Photo: Toyota)
Could there be an electronic cause of sudden acceleration embedded deep in your vehicle's sophisticated control system?
 
It's possible. After a series of inquiries, the federal auto safety agency announced that — despite earlier skepticism — it is investigating electronic interference as a possible cause.
 
Toyota's massive recalls were the result of sticky accelerator pedals and interfering floor mats, and they've been made more urgent by recent deaths. There have been as many as 2,000 cases of unintended acceleration in Toyota vehicles, and a reported 16 fatalities and 243 injuries. When cars take off by themselves, all causes of unintended acceleration have to be investigated. We turn off cell phones and computers on airplanes because of possible electronic interference, and modern cars could have a related "crosstalk" problem. The culprit may not be your cell phone, but dueling signals generated from inside your car or truck.
 
To help explain the situation more fully, some background is in order:
 
Last August, California Highway Patrol Officer Mark Saylor, his wife Cleofe, his daughter Mahalia, and brother-in-law Chris Lastrella were on the road in a 2009 Lexus ES 350, borrowed from their local dealer because the regular Toyota was in the shop.
 
It was 6:30 p.m. Without warning, the car began accelerating uncontrollably, finally reaching 100 mph on northbound Route 125 in Santee.
 
Lastrella had a cell phone, called 911, and the following conversation was recorded:
 
Lastrella: We’re on North 125 and our accelerator is stuck.
 
911 dispatcher: I’m sorry?
 
Lastrella: Our accelerator is stuck. We're on 125.
 
911dDispatcher: Northbound 125. What are you passing?
 
Lastrella: We’re going 120. Mission Gorge. We’re in trouble. We can't … there is no brakes. End freeway half mile.
 
911 dispatcher: You can’t do anything like turn off your engine?
 
Lastrella: We’re approaching the intersection. We’re approaching the intersection. We’re approaching the intersection.
 
With voices inside the car shouting “hold on” and “pray,” the Lexus slammed into the rear of a Ford Explorer, hopped a curb, and burst through a fence before rolling down an embankment, becoming airborne and rolling several times before bursting into flames in the San Diego River Basin. All four people on board were killed.
 
The Saylors’ car was equipped with all-weather floormats, which can interfere with the gas pedals under certain conditions. And it had inappropriate ones installed, which increase the likelihood of that being the cause in this case.
 
Only a few months later, however, just after Christmas, there was a second horrific accident. In Southlake, Texas, a 2008 Toyota Avalon plummeted into a pond after it began racing out of control. This crash also killed four people, members of a Jehovah’s Witnesses group.
  
The floor mats? They were in the trunk. Weeks after the fatal crash, Southlake police were still baffled as to the cause. “I think they may get there by at least determining what didn't cause the accident, help them at least get closer to the truth,” said Lt. Ben Brown.
 
It is at least possible that the Texas tragedy was the result of electronic interference with the “throttle-by-wire” systems in modern cars. In other words, there is no direct mechanical connection between the driver’s pedal inputs and the throttle’s response — it’s an electronic connection. 
 
Both Toyota and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) say they have thoroughly investigated electronic causes, and Toyota Motor Sales President Jim Lentz said yesterday, “It is not an electronics issue.”
 
But there is evidence that federal regulators did encounter an issue. In a 2008 report based on an investigation of a 2007 Lexus ES-350, the researchers wrote, “Magnetic fields were introduced in proximity to the throttle body and accelerator pedal potentiometers and did result in an increase in engine revolutions per minute (RPM) of up to approximately 1,000 rpm, similar to a cold-idle engine rpm level.”
 
Still they went on to conclude that the car’s systems had “multiple redundancies” and “showed no vulnerabilities to electrical signal activities.” In a follow-up phone call, a NHTSA source said that the agency had conducted a “thorough investigation,” but he asked not to be identified.
 
“The same report said that 600 ES-350 owners were surveyed by NHTSA, and 59 said they’d experienced incidents of unintended acceleration. I was struck by that,” said Jake Fisher of Consumer Reports, who was also looking at the federal report. Fisher also notes that the report found that many ES-350 owners had problems shifting into neutral (because of the car's serpentine shift pattern) and did not know how to quickly turn off the engine (which uses a start button). He advises consumers to follow through with getting their cars fixed if they were subject to the recall, and to familiarize themselves with how to put their cars in neutral and turn off the engine.
 
There is likely to be more than one thing behind these incidences of unintended acceleration. An electronic cause is championed by Clarence Ditlow, executive director of the Nader-inspired Center for Auto Safety, who dispatched a Freedom of Information Act request to NHTSA in search of documents on its investigation. Examining that data, he said it appears that the agency’s work amounts to less than the thorough investigation cited by the official.
 
Electronic interference would not leave a trail for investigators to follow. “In some ways it is the perfect defect,” Ditlow said, “because when one examines the vehicle there’s no failed part — such as a stuck accelerator — to find.”
 
In my own investigations of this issue, I’ve heard many eyewitness reports indicating that the car just suddenly took off — sometimes from idle at a stop sign. This would be unlikely if the cause was a jammed pedal (though it might result from floor mat ingress). The owner of a 2008 Camry LE wrote, “The car started accelerating on its own and forcing the brake pedal down and pumping it wouldn’t stop it. After about five minutes, it settled down and went at regular speed.”
 
CTS Corp., the Elkhart, Indiana firm that makes the 5.3 million pedal assemblies that Toyota has recalled, makes just this point. “CTS believes that the rare slow return pedal phenomenon, which may occur in extreme environmental conditions, should absolutely not be linked with any sudden unintended acceleration incidents,” the company said. 
 
“CTS is also not aware of any accidents and injuries caused by the rare slow return pedal condition, to the best of its knowledge. CTS wishes to clarify that it does not, and has never made, any accelerator pedals for Lexus vehicles and that CTS also has no accelerator pedals in Toyota vehicles prior to model year 2005. 
 
The company added, “We are disappointed that, despite these facts, CTS accelerator pedals have been frequently associated with the sudden unintended acceleration problems and incidents in various media reports.”
 
So if the pedals did not cause either the Texas or California crashes, and if the Texas crash involved no floormats at all — what are we talking about here? This is a dramatically unfolding story; expect major developments soon.
 
 
Related on MNN:

MNN homepage photo: daboost/iStockphoto

CLOSE link:
The opinions expressed by MNN Bloggers and those providing comments are theirs alone, and do not reflect the opinions of MNN.com. While we have reviewed their content to make sure it complies with our Terms and Conditions, MNN is not responsible for the accuracy of any of their information.
« Previous
Sudden acceleration: What to do when it happens to you		   Next »
Should I drive my Toyota?

Comments(9)

Sort by:
Posted By Anonymous - Tue, Feb 09 2010 at 4:49 PM EST

Sudden acceleration: Electronic interference could be a cause

It amazes me that a State Highway Patrolman doesn't know how to stop a vehicle that is speeding out of control. I am sure he has been trained for such an issue. I am sure that there is a lot more to this then Toyota is willing to share.

Posted By mary beth marks - Sun, Feb 07 2010 at 2:07 PM EST

Sudden Acceleration: Electronic could be the cause

I think it would be a good idea to inform people how to turn off their engines if this situation occurs. My instinct would have been to turn off the car, but I was not aware that I needed to be in Neutral to do that! The Police officer in the story may have been able to save his families lives had he known!

And may I ask , if you turn off your engine in this manner, do you have access to your breaks? Do you use you emergency brake?

Posted By Toyota Friend - Sat, Feb 06 2010 at 3:23 PM EST

2009 Toyota Corolla Steering Problem

I think it's a firmware or software issue for the "undisclosed" Power steering veering surge. The EPS sensor I think is the cause. Please do a report on this unspoken issue long before the gas pedal.

Posted By Michelle - Fri, Feb 05 2010 at 12:43 PM EST

My Prius tries to jump into traffic

This is scary! My car hasn't done anything this extreme but my '05 Prius tries to lurch forward from a complete standstill all the time, whenever it switches from fully electric to the gas engine while I'm sitting with my foot on the brake. It's not the same as the stories of extreme acceleration that I've read & heard recently, but it was very scary at first. The car suddenly revs up the idle and has significantly more power whenever the gas engine switches on so I have to be sure to.... More

Posted By Dave Towert - Thu, Feb 04 2010 at 1:09 AM EST

I was nearly killed by 'sudden acceleration'

It's real and I believe some kind of electronic glitch. I was nearly killed by sudden acceleration in my RAM 1500. Chrysler refused to take the incident seriously. Here is the story with graphics:
http://imimpulsive.blogspot.com/2010/01/stuck-throttle-accelerator-that-...

And here's the aftermath: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rXbJ6p4NAmA

It makes me nervous knowing there are these time bombs out there, not just for the drivers like me, but other drivers too and pedestrians (I ended up on the

Posted By Justin Whitmore - Wed, Feb 03 2010 at 9:42 PM EST

Scary

So is that why you cant use your cell phone on an airplane? Wow, scary.

RT
www.web-privacy.cz.tc

Posted By Steve - Wed, Feb 03 2010 at 1:44 PM EST

What is your point?

I own a Camry and appreciate all the research and speculation into the reasons behind the acceleration issue. However, what was your point by mentioning the religion of the victims in one of the crashes? Were the Saylors Catholics, Baptists or what? You failed to provide that vital bit of info for their crash. How about the owner of the 2008 Camry LE? Knowing his/her religion would have truly enhanced your piece. Can you explain?

Posted By jennyli59 - Wed, Feb 03 2010 at 12:38 PM EST

I think there's something to this

many times problems arise because there's something new in the environment that didn't exist in user testing, etc. This is an unknown to a car engineer...and I could see this being plausible. It's like designing an airplane but not thinking about the geese on the runway at La Guardia

Posted By Danny Haszard - Wed, Feb 03 2010 at 12:21 PM EST

Sudden acceleration: Electronic interference could be a cause

Lifelong Jehovah's Witnesses dissident speaks out on JW belief system . A) They are at your door to recruit you for their watchtower society corporation,they will say that "we are just here to share a message from the Bible" this is deception right off. B) Their 'message' creed is a false Gospel that Jesus had his second coming in 1914.The problem with this is it's not just a cute fairy tale,Jesus warned of the false prophets who would claim "..look he is here in the wilderness,or see here.... More

Add your comment

You can’t fool Mother Nature
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA