x
  • Bookmark and ShareShare
  • Earn Points
    What's this?
Are soy candles really 'better'?
Vegetable-based soy wax isn’t 100 percent perfect, but it’s a heck of a lot better than 'gas wax.'

By

Matt Hickman
Mon, Oct 19 2009 at 5:03 AM
 8

Related Topics:

Pollution, Toxins & Chemicals
Q: I was reading your recent column that tackled exfoliant-obsessed Becky’s microbead quandary and it dawned on me that I also have an otherwise innocent addiction that may be bad for the Earth: scented candles. I love ’em — cranberry votives, cilantro lime pillars, pumpkin spice tapers, lavender floaters, you name it … every time I get within a 10-mile radius of Ye Olde Candle Shoppe, I get heart palpitations. I keep on seeing soy candles around and hearing about how they are “better,” but I’m not exactly sure why. Wax is wax, right? Care to fill me in?
 
Sayonara,
Ali, Reseda, Calif.
 
A: Put down those kitchen matches for a minute, get yourself into a Zen state of mind, and listen to the soy wax sensei. I, like you, have a thing for scented candles and will openly admit that I once bought one from a fancy French brand that starts with “D” and ends in “E” that cost me approximately $70. I must have been wearing my bad idea jeans that day …
 
Anyway, buying and burning candles isn’t the most eco-egregious thing you can do out there. They’re relaxing (especially with a little John Tesh on in the background), they smell good (most of the time), and they make for interesting interior décor items (especially when molded into the shape of animals). But yes, those rumors you’ve heard about soy wax candles are indeed correct. They are “better” and you should be buyin’ and burnin’ them instead of standard wax varieties.
 
Here’s why: Candle wax is made from the petroleum byproduct, paraffin. Burning a paraffin wax candle, even if it smells like scrumptious apple pie, is like inviting a diesel truck into your home to let off some exhaust … the soot from both diesel fuel and paraffin wax contains a noxious mix of carcinogenic petro-carbon nastiness that can mess with your health, blacken the inside of your home, and emit toxic chemicals like benzene and toluene. Gross. And as you probably know, petroleum isn’t exactly renewable.
 
Vegetable-based soy wax isn’t 100 percent perfect (as with many agricultural products) but it’s a heck of a lot better than “gas wax.” They’re longer burning (with none of that soot), come in just as many tantalizing scents, and often the companies who produce soy candles go all out by using recycled-content packaging and lead-free paper/cotton wicks. Most candle shops and home boutiques should carry soy candle lines and if they don’t, make a request. Just make sure they’re 100 percent soy wax.
 
In my own home, I’m burning hand-poured-in-Philly soy candles from Duross and Langel. They’re affordable and come in a ton of potent scents; I recommend pear, acai and monkey grass. And in my fantasy home, I’m burning spendy, stunningly packaged (in vintage tin) Le Labo soy candles.
 
You see, Ali-san, it’s pretty straightforward. Unless you dig indoor air pollution, choose soy — once an underdog but now a formidable opponent in the natural vs. chemical candle wax showdown. Go on and burn bright, my friend. My training here is done.
 
Got a question? Submit a question to Mother Nature and one of our many experts will track down the answer. Plus: Visit our advice archives to see if your question has already been tackled.
 
Photo: Courtesy Duross and Langel
MNN homepage photo: MentalArt/iStockphoto

You might also like:

Join the conversation

Comments: 8
Sign in with one of these accounts to add your comment.
john_1031
john_1031 Mar 22 2013 at 11:45 AM
As one of the only candle manufactures (as far as I know) we actually tested our natural soy candle at Eurofins Product Testing in Denmark (we are located in Denmark). And we came out with a “no additive” result (yes we are proud). However, our competitors are full of benzene etc. and it looks like the higher price, the more chemicals. Very surprising and very much opposite what we thought. Also we tested our soy candle up against a paraffin candle in a sophisticated particle scanner and found
.... More
our candle to have 10x fewer particles. Now we have initiated a rather large scale test program of soy, paraffin, stearin, beeswax and others at the University of Copenhagen to get hard evidence for the quantity of particles, the shape of the particles and the quantity of nano size particles. This should bring the discussion of “which candle material is the best” to an end. Results follow in April (maybe May). Advertisement is not allowed, I know. However, I don't think US consumers will find a small Danish candle that interesting that is can be considered as advertisement. But I don believe the results are interesting and should be published. If the MNN will allow the "advertisement" of this post, the cutting edge results will be posted on our ByRansborg fb page in April or May in English.
|
anonymous
buy soy candles Feb 07 2012 at 12:19 AM

I just came onto your post and found it quite interesting. I am also associated with soy candles and love to enjoy the stuff on the same as its rarely found on internet. Thanks

|
anonymous
Mr. Poet Sep 13 2011 at 8:50 PM
Seriously, people should consider serious study into subjects instead of blogging your heart out. If paraffin "carcinogens" are that harmful, let's do this: toss out every toaster, gas stove, and electric heater we have, along with the ovens (except convection) also (if you study hard enough, you'll see they are as/more harmful). In addition, I think that every child who accidentally drops food on the stove so that it burns and emits carbon should be punished, for allowing such filthy air into the
.... More
house. I mean, although we are CARBON based life forms, burning carbons and separating carbon molecules every day, carbon is still evil! Lastly, no one should look into facts, we should just read blogs on the internet. This is a student in a University, with "Just the facts, ma'am" saying, "That's all folks!"
|
anonymous
Alderfall Oct 20 2009 at 12:06 PM
Hello there folks! I want to tout a wonderful alternative which is far greener and safe for all. Battery powered flameless candles. Yes, they are battery powered, which may sound bad at first, but think rechargeable NIMH batteries. Buy the new generation of NIMH batteries which are ready to use out of the package (make sure the package says this). They will hold a charge for months and months. Yes, they are maybe a bit less romantic compared to regular candles but no allergy issues and they are LED
.... More
technology, easy on the batteries (mine have to be recharged only once every couple of months and we run them every other day or so) and don't consume any kind of wax, petroleum or vegetable based. They are just as cheap or cheaper than the regular candles, I have never spent more than $10 for one, and they are usually found for under $6. They also come scented, if you are interested.
|
anonymous
Gordon Oct 19 2009 at 4:03 PM

I have an intolerance to Soy in food, are Soy candles going to create a problem for me and others with like sensitivity?

|
mhickman's picture
Matt Hickman Oct 19 2009 at 5:12 PM
Hi Gordon, Great question and also an important one since soy candles are touted as a safe alternative for folks with sensitivities to regular paraffin wax candles. From what I understand, how you react to inhaling a soybean-based candle depends on the severity of your allergies. Some folks may experience slight irritation while others may experience none at all. I'd check in with your MD before trying one out. You also may want to look into beeswax candles, another more eco-friendly alternative
.... More
to traditional wax. Whatever you choose, just make sure to check a candle label to see exactly what the wax is made from. Cheers, Matt
|
anonymous
Kirsten@Nexyoo Oct 19 2009 at 12:20 PM

Beeswax candles are environmentally-friendly, and come in scented versions. I think they're a great alternative to regular candles.

|
anonymous
A. Beekeeper Oct 28 2009 at 2:32 AM
I'm biased, being a beekeeper, but beeswax is the way to go... utterly renewable, if a bit pricey. And clean(er) burning. And they smell so subtly wonderful. Bees help feed us, as does soy, but beeswax is a byproduct of a larger need - sustainable agriculture. Palm wax, also clean burning is not a good choice due to the environmental destruction associated with it. Soy wax is a very reasonable choice, but... if you want the very best, unprocessed, nature wax to choose from, beeswax is without peer.
|

EDITORS' PICKS

tease Pope Francis

line

tease tree-dwelling animals

line

tease Internet shaming

Advertisement

MNN'S ADVICE TEAM

Matt Hickman (Mondays)
Eco-friendly blogger.
Morieka Johnson (Wednesdays)
Beauty and pets aficionado.
Chanie Kirschner (Fridays)
Smart and funny maven. 
Best of MNN
Some of our favorite Q&As.
Vanessa Vadim
Eco-activist and consultant.
Lazy Environmentalist 
Author and television host.

NEWSLETTER

Mother Nature. Delivered
Advertisement