• Welcome
  • Community
  • Blogs
  • Photos
  • Join
  • Log in
Follow MNN    
MNN - Mother Nature Network - Envrionmental News
improve your world
Friday, February 10, 2012
  • Earth Matters

    Browse All » Animals Weather Energy Politics Space Translating Uncle Sam Wilderness & Resources

  • Health

    Browse All » Allergies Fitness & Well-Being Healthy Spaces

  • Lifestyle

    Browse All » Arts & Culture Travel Natural Beauty & Fashion Recycling Responsible Living

  • GREEN TECH

    Browse All » Computers Gadgets & Electronics Research & Innovations Transportation

  • Eco-Biz & Money

    Browse All » Green Workplace Personal Finance Sustainable Business Practices

  • Food & Drink

    Browse All » Beverages Healthy Eating Recipes

  • Your Home

    Browse All » At Home Organic Farming & Gardening Remodeling & Design

  • family

    Browse All » Babies & Pregnancy Family Activities Pets Protection & Safety

Tweet
Pin It
Email Bookmark and ShareShare
WorldShares lets you earn donations for your favorite nonprofit. Earn up to 20 points now.
Learn More

Earn Points
What's this?
MNN.COM›Your Home›

Organic Farming & Gardening

Is there environmentally friendly milk?

The 'greenest' milk may be bought from a local dairy that has only pasture-fed cows, but the milk might not be certified organic.

By Chanie KirschnerFri, Feb 12 2010 at 5:19 AM EST
 21

Editor's note: This story has been updated from its original version to correct inaccuracies.
 
Q: Is there such a thing as environmentally friendly milk?

A: A simple question with a not-so-simple answer. The short answer is that yes, there is such a thing. But not everyone agrees on which milk is the most eco-friendly.
 
I recently asked the same question to myself as my bouncing baby boy has just turned 1, and I can finally make the transition from formula to milk (hallelujah, praise the Lord!). Of course, after I had done all my research and already purchased a fresh gallon of ultra-pasteurized organic whole milk from the store, I found out from my pediatrician that my wee one’s sensitive stomach earned him two months of rice milk before we can try anything else. So now I have a gallon container of whole milk still sitting in my fridge, creeping toward its expiration date.
 
There’s no greater pressure than racing against the expiration date on a milk container. What am I supposed to do with whole milk anyway? I’m not about to use it in my cereal (cringe).
 
I can tell you though that milk does a body good, but the cows in most of the farms it comes from? Not so much. I know I’ve always pictured milking cows as happy cows pasturing on lush green fields under a bright blue sky, save for a billowy white cloud here and there. And somewhere there are birds chirping. But that ain’t really what happens.
 
While many cows are often given healthy feed like whole shell corn, there are times when the picture is not always so rosy. Michael Pollan, a renowned author on topics related to the food industry, has written about "chicken litter" that is sometimes fed to cows. Some cows are also injected with hormones, although there is a growing trend -- partly based on consumer demand -- for hormone-free milk products.
 
An alternative is buying organic milk, which promises to the consumer that the cows that are giving the milk don’t get any hormones or antibiotics and are grass-fed. But not all organic milk is created equal. Large milk companies like Horizon Organic have come under fire in recent years about the USDA’s organic requirement of cows having “access to pasture” — many claim that they have just that — access. Maybe once or twice a day, maybe once or twice a week. Organic milk purists say that cows need to be out pasturing much more than that.
 
In 2008, after much prodding (pun intended) the USDA proposed a change to the vague “access to pasture” wording. The proposal was finally passed just a couple of weeks ago. Organic Valley, one large-scale organic milk producer, claims to be doing its part to remedy the problem.
 
Another alternative to buying organic is simply to find a local dairy that has only pasture-fed cows and doesn’t use injectable hormones or antibiotics. Many times, this will be the “greenest” milk, though it may not necessarily be certified organic. Try localharvest.org or eatwild.com to find a local dairy.
 
Though the debate over which milk is eco-friendliest may not be black and white, green milk is easy to find, if you know where to look. Just check out that gallon in the back of my fridge in a month.
 
— Chanie
 
Got a question? Submit a question to Mother Nature and one of our many experts will track down the answer. Plus: Visit our advice archives to see if your question has already been tackled.
 
Photo: THEPALMER/iStockphoto

 

CLOSE link:
You might also like:
Related Topics: Animal Research, Buy Local, Organic Farming

Comments

Follow this conversation
Add your comment
View:
  • All (21)

anonymous
C Fen 02/20/2010 22:02 PM

I'm a bit surprised that an article written on a site call "Mother Nature Network" was written by a formula using mom. Formula is most likely the reason for you 'wee one's sensitive stomach'. Interesting that your Doc recommended rice milk instead of cow milk, but didn't tell you to go with the breast when you chose formula.

  • |
  • Reply
  • report this post 

anonymous
Jim Dombrouski 02/19/2010 09:50 AM

When my granddaughter was on formula (at about age 6 months) I found an organic dairy in PA (we live in MD, where the state dictates what foods we can eat) where I purchase organic pastured milk from happy Jersey cows. My granddaughter is now 11 months old and thriving on the organix raw milk.

I make kefir from the same milk, which is wonderful and nutritious. It is a very healthy probiotic.

You can go to eatwild.com to find a farm near you that provides organic raw milk.... More

  • |
  • Reply
  • report this post 

anonymous
Claire 02/15/2010 22:55 PM

Milk is really good from a mother's breast when you are a baby (the same species as you). I thought you were supposed to drink milk until I realized my health had inproved drastically after I gave it up. I gave it up because In the coarse of becoming informed about my food I learned how cruel the dairy industry is (a large portion of the cruelty is inherent like seperating calfs and slaughtering the males for veal). My skin, allergies, asthma, weight, energy and sinus problems have all been.... More

  • |
  • Reply
  • report this post 

anonymous
David Worcester 02/15/2010 20:03 PM

I hear no one suggesting the ridiculous notion of pasteurizing mother's milk. It is highly healthy and beneficial directly from the breast. So, why tamper with cows milk?

Pasteurization was given the hard sell to a reluctant America because cows had come to be kept in unsanitary, cramped conditions, where they were poorly fed. The resulting milk yields saw a dramatic decline in quality and a carrier for disease for what had been, for hundreds if not thousands of years, an outstandingly.... More

  • |
  • Reply
  • report this post 

anonymous
David Worcester 02/15/2010 20:09 PM

http://www.archive.org/details/ChefJemTheRawMilk...

  • |
  • Reply
  • report this post 

anonymous
David Worcester 02/15/2010 20:12 PM

http:///the-raw-milk-controversy-full-version/jacobsonchiropractic.net

  • |
  • Reply
  • report this post 

anonymous
NYFarmer 02/15/2010 12:48 PM

Greetings from the NYC Milkshed. We're several thousand farmers who produce the milk for New York City and the rest of the New York Milkshed. For those of you interested in "foodshed" concepts, most US foodsheds, have their own milkshed. This is a surrounding region producing fresh milk. Different methods of milk production occur in the various milksheds of the country. I can only speak for the Northeast that I am so familiar with.
Just wishing that some of you who slam dairy.... More

  • |
  • Reply
  • report this post 

anonymous
Chris 02/15/2010 02:00 AM

You completely left out the impact of dairy cattle on climate change! Green eating is about more than organics and humane treatment of animals.

  • |
  • Reply
  • report this post 

anonymous
Pat 03/09/2010 17:37 PM

I'm sure glad we got rid of those 100 million bison on the great American prairie 140 years ago -- think of all that methane!

Good grief!

The American dairy industry has reduced its carbon footprint by 60 percent over the past 50 years. The beautiful countryside you see as you drive through many parts of America's milk-producing states is a result of dairying. Give farmers the credit they deserve -- they practice environmentalism EVERY day.

Michael Pollan is a smart,.... More

  • |
  • Reply
  • report this post 

anonymous
Dairy Boy 02/15/2010 10:59 AM

http://www.thefreelibrary.com/Vermont+dairy+installs+biodigester--sells+...

With a setup like this, the farmer captures the methane, burns it, which keeps it out of the atmosphere and lowers his need for fossil fuel energy inputs. Win Win

  • |
  • Reply
  • report this post 

anonymous
Dairy Boy 02/14/2010 21:00 PM

I run a small goat dairy in Texas and I can definitively tell you that milk can be produced sustainably. My farm operates with multiple bottom lines. First and foremost is animal welfare. We take this very seriously. All the boys born on our place go to a really nice farm where they are raised to slaughter weight on clean grassy pasture. The day comes for them and they are slaughtered humanely. In the wild goats face starvation, dying of thirst, and being ripped apart by predators. On.... More

  • |
  • Reply
  • report this post 

anonymous
Sterling Silver 02/13/2010 16:04 PM

As a dairy farmer's child who grew up milking and taking care of a 60 cow herd of gentle jerseys. I can only agree with the fact that there is no environmentally friendly way of consuming milk.

As many have observed, there is nothing more tragic than listen to a cow moan for its calf and a desperate calf bellowing for its mother. We used to leave the calves on the cow until the colostrum was consumed and many times we were able to keep the heifers as herd replacements. Frequently,.... More

  • |
  • Reply
  • report this post 

anonymous
david 02/13/2010 14:58 PM

Cruelty-free, environmentally friendly milk is not commercially available now but could be is an ahimsa standard were adopted. See:

http://vimeo.com/6727496
http://www.thelotustrust.org/ahimsa.html

  • |
  • Reply
  • report this post 

anonymous
Guest 02/13/2010 10:36 AM

Although many of these living conditions may be the present throughout much of the United States, where I live in Vermont, it couldn't be further from the truth. On my fifteen minute drive from home to school each day, I pass at least half a dozen farms that I know produce the milk I drink each day. On these mostly non-organic farms, cows are treated like family and the milk they produce couldn't be much better. Thus, those who say that milk production itself is a bad thing needs to realize.... More

  • |
  • Reply
  • report this post 

anonymous
Anonymous 02/13/2010 10:57 AM

...having my babies stolen immediately after birth and having my breasts constantly pumped for everyone but my own kin, then pass the soy milk please! Dysfunctional may be a common term to describe American families, but the family you describe sounds like a horror movie!

Beware of complacency and statements like "that's just the way things are done". There is nothing more dangerous than accepting the horrors other beings must endure because humans "eat meat and always will". I am being.... More

  • |
  • Reply
  • report this post 

anonymous
Guest 02/13/2010 10:29 AM

Milk consumption has been linked to obesity, certain types of cancer, and - despite what the well-funded dairy industry claims - is not the answer to osteoporosis.
Milk production (even so-called "organic" milk) causes serious water pollution and has other devastating environmental consequences.
Every time we drink a glass a milk, we are ensuring that a baby cow will be taken from his mother and killed shortly after birth so diners can consume veal.
Dairy cows on factory farms.... More

  • |
  • Reply
  • report this post 

anonymous
Carrie 02/13/2010 10:10 AM

For those who claim that "milk does a body good", it's important to ask why that is the case. Calcium, right? Where does calcium come from? Does the cow produce it out of thin air and secrete it from her udders for us to enjoy? Let's travel back in time to chemistry class for a second and recall that calcium is a mineral. Where do minerals come from? The ground! How do cows get calcium into their bodies? By eating plants that grow from the ground. Unfortunately, most milk cows don't.... More

  • |
  • Reply
  • report this post 

anonymous
Lee 02/12/2010 18:02 PM

While this article brings up some good points, it's impossible to overlook the inherent cruelty meted out to newborn calves. Organic diary farmers here in VT were shocked by undercover videos captured by the Humane Society of the US at Bushway Packing, a slaughterhouse (.... More

  • |
  • Reply
  • report this post 

anonymous
Bustopher 02/12/2010 16:27 PM

I'm not sure it is for the environment because I have to drive a long distance to get it but it is good for me. I am now off all drugs including asthma medication and bone density medication because I drink plenty of raw unpasteurized whole milk. My state allows cow share programs and the Jersey cows are pastured in a different state. While others buy drugs for their health, I buy milk. My lactose intolerant husband is fine with raw milk as it has lactase in it that helps him digest milk. .... More

  • |
  • Reply
  • report this post 

anonymous
Anonymous 02/13/2010 10:47 AM

They'd tell you how important that milk is to them and their babies. They'd tell you how they moan and cry when their new born babies are taken from them immediately after birth, never able to taste the life-giving substance that would allow them to grow up strong and healthy. The cow doesn't care what humans do to her milk after she secretes it--whether it's heated or consumed raw. All she knows is what she has been through for that human "pleasure" and how little she has to show for it.More

  • |
  • Reply
  • report this post 

anonymous
danielle 02/12/2010 15:27 PM

"I can tell you though that milk does a body good" recent science disproves this. Also, there is NO WAY milk can be produced sustainably. Ask yourself what happens to the baby male claves that are born and how the cows have to continually be pregant and then maybe you can put the pieces together...

  • |
  • Reply
  • report this post 

Add your comment

Sign in with one of these accounts or just add your comment below.
    Log in or
    create an account
     
    Login
Used only for emailed comments and will not be displayed with your post
Notify me with an email when other people comment on this article.
The posting of advertisement, profanity or personal attacks is prohibited.
Click here to review our Terms of Use

tease to ecollywood

tease to squatter

tease to toxic plants for cats

ADVERTISEMENT

MNN'S ADVICE TEAM

Matt Hickman (Mondays)
Eco-friendly blogger.
Morieka Johnson (Wednesdays)
Beauty and pets aficionado.
Chanie Kirschner (Fridays)
Smart and funny maven. 
Best of MNN
Some of our favorite Q&As.
Vanessa Vadim
Eco-activist and consultant.
Lazy Environmentalist 
Author and television host.
TOP MEMBERSJoin Now
  • poland.jr
    21026 points
  • ecomainegirl
    9398 points
  • achase
    9323 points
  • LauraB
    5049 points
  • Momof2
    4514 points
All members

SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTER

CONNECT WITH MNN

Follow @twitterapi
 Tumblr
 Google +

ADVERTISEMENT



Quick Links

  • About Us
  • Advisory Board
  • Editors' Blog
  • Press
  • Privacy
  • Sitemap
  • Terms of Service
  • WorldShares

MNN Tools

  • Advice
  • Blogs
  • Day in History
  • Eco-glossary
  • Infographics
  • Lists
  • Photos
  • Videos

Connect

  • Community
  • Contact Us
  • Contests
  • Idea Lab
  • Mixed Greens
  • Newsletters
  • Polls
  • RSS

Channels

  • Earth Matters
  • Health
  • Lifestyle
  • Green Tech
  • Eco-Biz & Money
  • Your Home
  • Family
  • State Reports
 

Copyright © 2012 MNN Holdings, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Website by GLICK INTERACTIVE | Powered by CIRRACORE
 
SPONSORS